Find & study this chapter
Look closer
Notice a repeated word. Compare a reading. Keep a question for your next study.
Explore The King’s Bible · External KJV resources, opening in a new tab.
2 Maccabees — Parallel Reader
Study Notes for 2 Maccabees 5 · Chapter summaries, translation research and open questions.

2 Maccabees · 3 English readings
2 Maccabees 5
Read this passage across the published editions. Choose the translations you want to see.
About the texts and verse alignment
Bespoke Saints English is the reading edition. Study Workspace research and quotations use the existing comparison sources. The other columns show the English readings available in this book’s existing comparison studies. Follow a source link beside any reading to open its original study and source assessment.
Rows follow this book’s published reading and comparison references. Original source references remain beside each reading, including grouped verses and different numbering. A missing match is labelled; another translation is never substituted for it. The source studies’ review and numbering limits still apply.
On a small screen, swipe the table sideways or hide columns.
| Verse | Bespoke Saints EnglishGreek–English | Latin–EnglishClementine Vulgate · English rendering | King JamesKing James Version · Apocrypha |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5:1 | 5:1 ↗ About this time Antiochus organized his second expedition into Egypt. | 5:1 ↗ At the same time, Antiochus prepared a second expedition into Egypt. | KJV 5:1 ↗ About the same time Antiochus prepared his second voyage into Egypt: |
| 5:2 | 5:2 ↗ Throughout the whole city, for nearly forty days, horsemen were seen racing through the air, wearing robes interwoven with gold, armed with lances and arrayed in squadrons; there were drawn swords, | 5:2 ↗ For forty days, throughout the whole city of Jerusalem, riders were seen rushing through the air, wearing robes adorned with gold and armed with spears like companies of soldiers. | KJV 5:2 ↗ And then it happened, that through all the city, for the space almost of forty days, there were seen horsemen running in the air, in cloth of gold, and armed with lances, like a band of soldiers, |
| 5:3 | 5:3 ↗ formations of cavalry, attacks and countercharges on either side, movements of shields, masses of spears, volleys of missiles, flashes of golden ornaments, and armour of every kind. | 5:3 ↗ There were charges of horses arranged in ranks, close encounters, movements of shields, a multitude wearing helmets with swords drawn, the casting of missiles, and the splendor of gold armor and breastplates of every kind. | KJV 5:3 ↗ And troops of horsemen in array, encountering and running one against another, with shaking of shields, and multitude of pikes, and drawing of swords, and casting of darts, and glittering of golden ornaments, and harness of all sorts. |
| 5:4 | 5:4 ↗ Therefore everyone prayed that the manifestation had come for good. | 5:4 ↗ Therefore everyone prayed that the portents might turn out for good. | KJV 5:4 ↗ Wherefore every man prayed that that apparition might turn to good. |
| 5:5 | 5:5 ↗ When a false rumor arose that Antiochus had departed this life, Jason took no fewer than a thousand men and suddenly attacked the city. Those on the wall were driven back, and when the city was finally being taken, Menelaus fled to the citadel. | 5:5 ↗ When a false report spread that Antiochus had died, Jason took no fewer than a thousand men and suddenly attacked the city. As the citizens rushed to the wall, the city was finally taken, and Menelaus fled into the citadel. | KJV 5:5 ↗ Now when there was gone forth a false rumour, as though Antiochus had been dead, Jason took at the least a thousand men, and suddenly made an assault upon the city; and they that were upon the walls being put back, and the city at length taken, Menelaus fled into the castle: |
| 5:6 | 5:6 ↗ Jason slaughtered his own fellow citizens without mercy, not realizing that success against his kinsmen was the greatest misfortune. He imagined he was setting up trophies over enemies rather than his own countrymen. | 5:6 ↗ Jason showed no restraint in slaughtering his fellow citizens. He did not consider that success against his own kin was the greatest evil, imagining that he would take trophies from enemies, not from fellow citizens. | KJV 5:6 ↗ But Jason slew his own citizens without mercy, not considering that to get the day of them of his own nation would be a most unhappy day for him; but thinking they had been his enemies, and not his countrymen, whom he conquered. |
| 5:7 | 5:7 ↗ He did not gain control of the government; receiving shame as the outcome of his plot, he again went away as a fugitive into the Ammonite country. | 5:7 ↗ Yet he did not obtain the office; instead he received disgrace as the outcome of his plots, and once more went away as a fugitive into Ammonite territory. | KJV 5:7 ↗ Howbeit for all this he obtained not the principality, but at the last received shame for the reward of his treason, and fled again into the country of the Ammonites. |
| 5:8 | 5:8 ↗ In the end he met a disastrous conclusion. Accused before Aretas, ruler of the Arabs, he fled from city to city, pursued by everyone, hated as a deserter of the laws and abhorred as the executioner of his homeland and fellow citizens, until he was driven into Egypt. | 5:8 ↗ Finally, confined to his own ruin by Aretas, ruler of the Arabs, he fled from city to city. Hated by everyone as a deserter of the laws and abhorred as an enemy of his homeland and fellow citizens, he was driven into Egypt. | KJV 5:8 ↗ In the end therefore he had an unhappy return, being accused before Aretas the king of the Arabians, fleeing from city to city, pursued of all men, hated as a forsaker of the laws, and being had in abomination as an open enemy of his country and countrymen, he was cast out into Egypt. |
| 5:9 | 5:9 ↗ He who had made many strangers to their homeland perished in a foreign land, having sailed to the Lacedaemonians in the hope of obtaining shelter because of their kinship. | 5:9 ↗ He who had driven many from their homeland perished abroad, having gone to the Spartans as though he would find refuge there because of their kinship. | KJV 5:9 ↗ Thus he that had driven many out of their country perished in a strange land, retiring to the Lacedemonians, and thinking there to find succour by reason of his kindred: |
| 5:10 | 5:10 ↗ He who had thrown out multitudes unburied went unmourned and received neither any funeral care whatever nor a place in his ancestral tomb. | 5:10 ↗ He who had cast out many unburied was himself cast out unmourned and unburied, receiving neither burial in a foreign land nor a share in his ancestral tomb. | KJV 5:10 ↗ And he that had cast out many unburied had none to mourn for him, nor any solemn funerals at all, nor sepulchre with his fathers. |
| 5:11 | 5:11 ↗ When news of these events reached the king, he concluded that Judea was in revolt. He therefore broke camp in Egypt, savage in spirit, took the city by force of arms, | 5:11 ↗ After these events, the king suspected that the Jews would abandon their alliance. For this reason he set out from Egypt with a savage spirit and took the city by force of arms. | KJV 5:11 ↗ Now when this that was done came to the king’s ear, he thought that Judea had revolted: whereupon removing out of Egypt in a furious mind, he took the city by force of arms, |
| 5:12 | 5:12 ↗ and ordered the soldiers to cut down without mercy those they met and slaughter those who went up into the houses. | 5:12 ↗ He ordered the soldiers to kill without sparing those they met, and to climb into the houses and slaughter people. | KJV 5:12 ↗ And commanded his men of war not to spare such as they met, and to slay such as went up upon the houses. |
| 5:13 | 5:13 ↗ There was killing of young and old, destruction of boys, women and children, and slaughter of virgins and infants. | 5:13 ↗ So there were slaughters of young and old, destruction of women and children, and killings of maidens and little ones. | KJV 5:13 ↗ Thus there was killing of young and old, making away of men, women, and children, slaying of virgins and infants. |
| 5:14 | 5:14 ↗ In the space of three days eighty thousand were lost: forty thousand in the acts of violence, and no fewer than those slaughtered were sold. | 5:14 ↗ Within three whole days, eighty thousand were killed, forty thousand were bound, and no fewer were sold. | KJV 5:14 ↗ And there were destroyed within the space of three whole days fourscore thousand, whereof forty thousand were slain in the conflict; and no fewer sold than slain. |
| 5:15 | 5:15 ↗ Not content with this, he dared to enter the holiest temple in all the earth, with Menelaus as guide—the man who had become a traitor to both the laws and his homeland. | 5:15 ↗ But these things were not enough: he even dared to enter the temple, holier than all the earth, with Menelaus as his guide, who had become a betrayer of the laws and his homeland. | KJV 5:15 ↗ Yet was he not content with this, but presumed to go into the most holy temple of all the world; Menelaus, that traitor to the laws, and to his own country, being his guide: |
| 5:16 | 5:16 ↗ With defiled hands he took the sacred vessels, and with profane hands swept away the gifts other kings had dedicated for the enhancement, glory and honour of the place. | 5:16 ↗ Taking the sacred vessels in his criminal hands, he handled them unworthily and defiled them—the vessels that other kings and cities had placed there for the adornment and glory of the place. | KJV 5:16 ↗ And taking the holy vessels with polluted hands, and with profane hands pulling down the things that were dedicated by other kings to the augmentation and glory and honour of the place, he gave them away. |
| 5:17 | 5:17 ↗ Antiochus was exalted in his mind, not seeing that the Master had been briefly angered because of the sins of those inhabiting the city, and therefore had disregarded the place. | 5:17 ↗ So estranged in mind was Antiochus that he did not consider that God had been angry for a little while because of the sins of the city's inhabitants, and that for this reason the place had suffered contempt. | KJV 5:17 ↗ And so haughty was Antiochus in mind, that he considered not that the Lord was angry for a while for the sins of them that dwelt in the city, and therefore his eye was not upon the place. |
| 5:18 | 5:18 ↗ Had they not happened to be involved in many sins, he too, like Heliodorus, whom King Seleucus sent to inspect the treasury, would have been scourged immediately upon advancing and thrown back from his rashness. | 5:18 ↗ Otherwise, had they not been entangled in many sins, he too would certainly have been scourged immediately upon his arrival and driven back from his audacity, as happened to Heliodorus, who was sent by King Seleucus to plunder the treasury. | KJV 5:18 ↗ For had they not been formerly wrapped in many sins, this man, as soon as he had come, had forthwith been scourged, and put back from his presumption, as Heliodorus was, whom Seleucus the king sent to view the treasury. |
| 5:19 | 5:19 ↗ But the Lord did not choose the nation for the sake of the place; He chose the place for the sake of the nation. | 5:19 ↗ But God did not choose the nation for the sake of the place; He chose the place for the sake of the nation. | KJV 5:19 ↗ Nevertheless God did not choose the people for the place’s sake, but the place for the people’s sake. |
| 5:20 | 5:20 ↗ Therefore the place itself, having shared in the nation’s misfortunes, afterward shared in its benefits. What had been abandoned in the Almighty’s anger was restored again in all glory when the great Master became reconciled. | 5:20 ↗ Therefore the place itself also shared in the people's misfortunes. Afterward it will share in their good things, and the place abandoned in the wrath of almighty God will again be exalted with the greatest glory when the great Lord is reconciled. | KJV 5:20 ↗ And therefore the place itself, that was partaker with them of the adversity that happened to the nation, did afterward communicate in the benefits sent from the Lord: and as it was forsaken in the wrath of the Almighty, so again, the great Lord being reconciled, it was set up with all glory. |
| 5:21 | 5:21 ↗ Antiochus, then, carried off eighteen hundred talents from the temple and quickly withdrew to Antioch. In his arrogance he imagined he could make the land navigable and the sea passable on foot, because of the haughtiness of his heart. | 5:21 ↗ Antiochus therefore took eighteen hundred talents from the temple and quickly returned to Antioch, imagining in his arrogance that he could make the land navigable and the sea passable on foot, so exalted was his mind. | KJV 5:21 ↗ So when Antiochus had carried out of the temple a thousand and eight hundred talents, he departed in all haste unto Antiochia, weening in his pride to make the land navigable, and the sea passable by foot: such was the haughtiness of his mind. |
| 5:22 | 5:22 ↗ He also left overseers to afflict the people: in Jerusalem, Philip, a Phrygian by birth, whose character was more barbarous than that of the man who appointed him; | 5:22 ↗ He also left governors to oppress the nation: at Jerusalem, Philip, a Phrygian by birth, more cruel in character than the very man who appointed him; | KJV 5:22 ↗ And he left governors to vex the nation: at Jerusalem, Philip, for his country a Phrygian, and for manners more barbarous than he that set him there; |
| 5:23 | 5:23 ↗ and at Gerizim, Andronicus; besides these, Menelaus, who exalted himself over his fellow citizens more wickedly than the others. Having a hateful disposition toward the Jewish citizens, | 5:23 ↗ and at Gerizim, Andronicus and Menelaus, who pressed more heavily upon the citizens than the others. | KJV 5:23 ↗ And at Garizim, Andronicus; and besides, Menelaus, who worse than all the rest bare an heavy hand over the citizens, having a malicious mind against his countrymen the Jews. |
| 5:24 | 5:24 ↗ he sent Apollonius, commander of the Mysians, with an army of twenty-two thousand, ordering him to slaughter all the men in their prime and sell the women and the younger people. | 5:24 ↗ Being set against the Jews, he sent the hateful commander Apollonius with an army of twenty-two thousand, ordering him to kill all those of mature age and sell the women and youths. | KJV 5:24 ↗ He sent also that detestable ringleader Apollonius with an army of two and twenty thousand, commanding him to slay all those that were in their best age, and to sell the women and the younger sort: |
| 5:25 | 5:25 ↗ On arriving in Jerusalem, Apollonius pretended to be peaceable and waited until the holy day of the Sabbath. Finding the Jews at rest, he ordered those under him to parade under arms. | 5:25 ↗ When Apollonius came to Jerusalem, he pretended peace and remained quiet until the holy Sabbath day. Then, while the Jews were resting, he ordered his men to take up arms. | KJV 5:25 ↗ Who coming to Jerusalem, and pretending peace, did forbear till the holy day of the sabbath, when taking the Jews keeping holy day, he commanded his men to arm themselves. |
| 5:26 | 5:26 ↗ He stabbed all who came out to watch, and rushing armed into the city, struck down considerable multitudes. | 5:26 ↗ He slaughtered everyone who had come out to watch, and running through the city with his armed men, killed an immense multitude. | KJV 5:26 ↗ And so he slew all them that were gone to the celebrating of the sabbath, and running through the city with weapons slew great multitudes. |
| 5:27 | 5:27 ↗ But Judas, also called Maccabeus, withdrew into the wilderness with about nine others. He and those with him lived in the mountains like wild animals, continually eating plants so as not to share in the defilement. | 5:27 ↗ But Judas Maccabeus, who was one of ten, had withdrawn to a deserted place. There he lived among the wild beasts in the mountains with his companions, and they remained there eating grass as food, so that they would not share in the defilement. | KJV 5:27 ↗ But Judas Maccabeus with nine others, or thereabout, withdrew himself into the wilderness, and lived in the mountains after the manner of beasts, with his company, who fed on herbs continually, lest they should be partakers of the pollution. |
Study Notes — 2 Maccabees
Chapter summaries, translation choices, historical interpretation and questions for further study.
Saints Translation · Study edition
2 Maccabees — Study Edition
Verse-by-verse research on the Saints Translation of 2 Maccabees, condensed: where the Greek, the Latin Vulgate and the King James Bible differ, why the differences arose, and how Jewish and Christian readers have understood the text.
About this study
This page condenses the verse-by-verse research behind the Saints English translation of 2 Maccabees, made from the Greek Septuagint in the Rahlfs–Hanhart edition (2006). The book was written in Greek, so there is no Masoretic Hebrew text; every verse is compared with the Latin Vulgate (the Clementine text) and with the King James Version, which printed 2 Maccabees among its Apocrypha. Each comparison records the difference in wording, how Catholic and Protestant readers explain the passage, how the saints and early Christian writers read it, a combined classification, and how the difference arose.
This is working research, not a finished critical edition. The Latin–Greek categories come from the project’s comparison edition and were checked on 6 October 2026, with a few changed; the KJV–Greek categories are new on that date (the KJV comparison page still says “classification pending”). These judgements were made by AI from the published texts and notes and await specialist review. No manuscripts or critical apparatus have been consulted directly.
Please note: Saints English is literal-poetic: accurate to the Greek, with the cadence of older English (“thou”, “hath”). The comparison pages still show an earlier modern-English draft of the Greek in their Greek column, so their wording can differ from the reading text; the reading text is authoritative.
How to read the notes
- Two comparisons stand behind every verse. Latin ↔ Greek sets the Vulgate beside the Septuagint, with Catholic and wider Christian reception. KJV ↔ Greek sets the King James Apocrypha beside the Greek, with Protestant commentary and the saints. There is no Hebrew text of this book to compare.
- Five categories describe each relationship: Same, Similar (a modest difference of expression), Different (a name, number, action or image), Divergent (material added, absent or rearranged) and Disparate (a major difference of meaning or consequence). They describe texts, not the standing of any tradition.
- Both the Old Latin and the KJV were translated from Greek, so most of their differences from the Saints reading come from other Greek manuscripts or printed editions, or from the translators’ own wording.
- Keep apart the narrator, a character speaking in the story, a later commentator, and this project’s own analysis. A difference is recorded without assuming what caused it.
Chapter and verse numbering
- Chapter and verse numbers follow the Greek; 2 Maccabees here has 555 verses. The book was written in Greek, so there is no Masoretic Hebrew text and the Hebrew–Greek comparison does not apply.
- The Latin of 2 Maccabees in the Vulgate is an Old Latin translation made from Greek, not a translation by Jerome. Its Latin–Greek categories were already assigned by the project’s comparison edition; this study checks them and changes some, each with its reason.
- The 1611 King James Bible printed 2 Maccabees among its Apocrypha, translated from Greek. In several places the Latin and the KJV follow other Greek copies than the critical text: at 8:35, for example, the edited Greek calls Nicanor ‘most fortunate’ in irony, while the Latin and KJV read “most unfortunate”.
Jump to a chapter
The two comparisons at a glance
Counts are per verse of the Greek (555 verse units). Every verse has a Latin counterpart. The Latin and KJV columns are new and provisional.
| Category | Latin ↔ Greek | KJV ↔ Greek |
|---|---|---|
| Same | 2 | 351 |
| Similar | 375 | 167 |
| Different | 133 | 30 |
| Divergent | 40 | 7 |
| Disparate | 5 | 0 |
| Total | 555 | 555 |
The full verse-by-verse record, with every source, is kept in the research file for 2 Maccabees.
Chapter by chapter
Chapters 1–4
2 Maccabees 1 · Letters to Egypt and the hidden altar fire
The Jews of Jerusalem write to the Jews of Egypt urging them to keep the feast of the temple’s purification, and tell how Nehemiah recovered the altar fire as a thick liquid that blazed up in the sun. The main differences come from the Clementine Latin, an Old Latin translation made from the Greek, which divides several verses differently and paraphrases; the KJV, translated from the Greek, follows the older verse division but otherwise stays close.
- 1:35 — The Greek says ‘The king received many different revenues and shared them with those whom he favoured’. The Latin has the king give “many good things and gift after gift” to the priests, distributing them with his own hand. The KJV follows the Greek (“took many gifts, and bestowed thereof”). The Latin names the priests as the recipients and drops the revenues.
- 1:9–1:10 — The date ‘In the one hundred eighty-eighth year’ closes the first letter in the Greek edition used here (Rahlfs). Both the Latin and the KJV put it at the head of 1:10, so it dates the second letter instead. This affects how the two letters are dated and separated.
- 1:12–1:13 — In the Greek God ‘drove out those arrayed against us in the holy city’, and the invading force is cut down at Nanea’s temple. The Latin has God make the enemies “surge forth from Persia” and has the commander alone fall. The KJV matches the Greek in both verses.
Disparate: Latin 1:35
Open questions
- Why would the dating of the second letter matter for how readers understand the origin of the feast of Dedication?
- Does the Latin’s reversed gift-giving in 1:35 reflect a misreading or a different Greek exemplar?
2 Maccabees 2 · Jeremiah hides the ark; the epitomist’s preface
The letter continues with Jeremiah hiding the tent, ark and incense altar in a cave, and with Nehemiah’s and Judas’s collections of books; then the author introduces his abridgement of Jason of Cyrene’s five books. Differences lie mostly in the Latin’s paraphrase of key words, with the KJV and Latin agreeing against the Greek in a few places.
- 2:13 — The Greek says Nehemiah gathered ‘the books concerning the kings and prophets, the writings of David’. The Latin has books “from the regions” in place of the kings. The KJV follows the Greek (“the acts of the kings”). The Greek reading links the library to the historical books of Israel.
- 2:21 — The Greek says the few ‘plundered the whole land’. The Latin has “recovered the whole region” and the KJV “overcame the whole country”. Both soften the Greek verb, presenting the campaign as recovery or victory rather than plunder.
- 2:17–2:18 — The Greek hopes that God ‘will soon have mercy on us and gather us from under heaven into the holy place’. The Latin places the closing clause about rescue in a separate verse (Latin 2:19). The KJV moves “We hope” to the start of 2:17 and adds “out of every land”.
Open questions
- Is the Greek ‘plundered’ in 2:21 meant as an image of reversal, the few despoiling the many?
- What does the epitomist’s comparison to a house painter suggest about how he viewed his own history?
2 Maccabees 3 · Heliodorus and the temple treasury
Simon’s quarrel with the high priest Onias leads the king to send Heliodorus to seize the temple treasury, but a heavenly horseman and two young men strike him down, and he is spared through Onias’s sacrifice. Textual differences concern the subject of Simon’s quarrel, where the virgins ran, and the divine titles.
- 3:4 — The Greek places Simon’s dispute with the high priest ‘over the administration of the city’s market’. The Latin has Simon attempting “something lawless in the city”, and the KJV has him fall out “about disorder in the city”. Greek manuscripts differ here, and the Latin and KJV reflect the reading about lawlessness.
- 3:19 — In the Greek some of the secluded virgins ‘ran together to the gateways’. The Latin has them run out “to Onias”, the high priest. The KJV agrees with the Greek (“some to the gates”). The Latin likely reflects a copying difference in its source.
- 3:24 — The Greek names God ‘the Sovereign of spirits and of all authority’. The Latin has “the Spirit of almighty God”, and the KJV “the Lord of spirits, and the Prince of all power”. The Latin title changes the sense from rule over spirits to God’s own Spirit.
Open questions
- Which reading in 3:4, market administration or lawlessness, fits the narrative better?
- What does Onias’s sacrifice for a hostile foreign official suggest about the role of the high priest?
2 Maccabees 4 · Jason, Menelaus and the buying of the high priesthood
Jason buys the high priesthood, builds a gymnasium in Jerusalem and pushes Greek customs; Menelaus then outbids him, robs the temple and arranges the murder of Onias. The main textual differences lie in the Old Latin (the early Latin version translated from Greek), which renders several rare Greek words differently.
- 4:12 — The Greek says Jason made the leading young men ‘wear the broad-brimmed hat’, the hat of the Greek god Hermes worn in the gymnasium. The Latin instead says he put them “in brothels”. The KJV keeps the hat. The Latin turns a cultural badge into open immorality.
- 4:29 — In the Greek both men leave deputies: Menelaus ‘left his own brother Lysimachus as his deputy’, and Sostratus left Crates. The Latin says Menelaus “was removed from the priesthood” and Sostratus “was placed over the Cypriots”. The KJV matches the Greek. The Latin turns Menelaus’s departure into a removal from office and puts Sostratus himself over the Cypriots; Crates is absent.
- 4:4 — The Greek names ‘Apollonius son of Menestheus’. The Latin speaks of his “frenzied efforts” and the KJV says Apollonius “did rage”. Both follow manuscripts where a Greek verb meaning “to rage” stands where modern editors restore the father’s name Menestheus.
Disparate: Latin 4:12
Open questions
- Why would the Old Latin translator read the Greek hat as brothels: a misunderstanding, or a moral gloss?
- Should the name Menestheus in 4:4 be preferred over the manuscript reading “to rage”?
Chapters 5–8
2 Maccabees 5 · Jason’s revolt and Antiochus’s plunder of the temple
Visions appear over Jerusalem, Jason attacks the city and dies in exile, and Antiochus storms Jerusalem and plunders the temple; Apollonius later massacres the people on a Sabbath. The differences concern the Latin and KJV readings of Greek titles, numbers and the narrator’s explanation of God’s anger.
- 5:24 — The Greek calls Apollonius ‘commander of the Mysians’. The Latin “hateful commander” and the KJV “that detestable ringleader” both read the Greek title as built on a word for “loathsome”. A troop title becomes a moral judgement in both.
- 5:23 — The Saints reading ends with ‘Having a hateful disposition toward the Jewish citizens’, leading into the king’s sending of Apollonius. The KJV gives the “malicious mind against his countrymen” to Menelaus; the Latin has it at the start of 5:24 (“being set against the Jews”). The Greek can be read either way.
- 5:8 — Jason was ‘Accused before Aretas, ruler of the Arabs’. The Latin says he was “confined”, matching a similar-looking Greek variant (shut in versus accused). The KJV has “accused”.
Open questions
- How does the future tense in the Latin of 5:20 change the narrator’s comment?
- Was Mysarch a real military title, or a play on a Greek word for loathsome?
2 Maccabees 6 · The persecution and the death of Eleazar
The temple is renamed for Olympian Zeus, Jewish practice is forbidden, and the aged scribe Eleazar dies rather than eat pork or pretend to. Differences are mostly Latin paraphrase, with one place-name change and a missing action.
- 6:1 — The king sent ‘an elderly Athenian’. The Latin has “an old man from Antioch”, reflecting a Greek variant; the KJV keeps “of Athens”.
- 6:19–20 — Eleazar goes to the torture frame ‘having spat it out’. The KJV moves “spit it forth” into 6:19; the Latin does not mention the spitting at all, recasting the clause as his inner resolve.
- 6:28 — The Greek says ‘he went immediately to the torture frame’, stressing his free choice. The Latin says he “was immediately dragged”, which loses the voluntary note; the KJV keeps “he went”.
Open questions
- Does Eleazar’s death read differently if he “went” rather than was “dragged” to the torture frame?
- Which Greek reading lies behind “the whole nation” in 6:31?
2 Maccabees 7 · The mother and her seven sons
Seven brothers and their mother are tortured to death for refusing pork, each confessing hope in resurrection and God’s justice. Differences lie in the Latin verse divisions, the Latin and KJV reading of a verb meaning both comfort and compassion, and the mother’s teaching on creation.
- 7:6 — The Saints reading has ‘He will have compassion on His servants’, quoting Deuteronomy 32:36. The Latin and KJV both have God “comforted” in his servants. The Greek verb carries both meanings; the choice shapes how God’s response to the martyrs is pictured.
- 7:28 — The mother says ‘God made them not from things that were’. The Latin turns this into “out of nothing” (ex nihilo), a phrase later central to the doctrine of creation; the KJV keeps “of things that were not”.
- 7:38 — The last son prays, ‘May the Almighty’s anger, justly brought upon our whole people, come to rest in me and my brothers.’ The KJV keeps the prayer; the Latin states it as fact (“will cease”), turning a plea into an assurance.
Open questions
- Does 7:28 teach creation out of nothing, or creation from unformed matter?
- Is the son’s offering in 7:37–38 a prayer that his death will atone for the nation?
2 Maccabees 8 · Judas defeats Nicanor
Judas gathers six thousand men, prays, and routs Nicanor, who had planned to pay Rome’s tribute by selling Jewish captives; the victors keep the Sabbath and share the spoils with widows and orphans. The main differences lie in the numbers and names given by the Latin, and in a few places where the Latin and the KJV follow other Greek readings.
- 8:20 — Judas recalls a battle in Babylonia: ‘eight thousand in all came to the engagement, with four thousand Macedonians’. The Latin says “six thousand” Jews fought alone after their Macedonian allies hesitated, and speaks of “benefits” rather than spoil. The KJV keeps the Greek figures.
- 8:16 — The Greek and the KJV give Judas ‘six thousand in number’, matching 8:1. The Latin has “seven thousand,” and urges the men not to “come to terms with” the enemy rather than not to be terrified of them.
- 8:21–23 — In the Greek, Judas divides the army into four, with Eleazar as fourth leader, and himself reads ‘the sacred book’. The Latin omits the four divisions and has “Ezra” read the book. The KJV has Judas appoint “Eleazar to read the holy book.” These probably reflect different Greek readings of the names and verbs.
Disparate: Latin 8:20
Open questions
- Why might the Latin and Greek remember the size of the Babylonian force so differently?
- What does reading the sacred book before battle suggest about how the war was understood?
Chapters 9–12
2 Maccabees 9 · The death of Antiochus Epiphanes
Antiochus, driven from Persepolis, vows to destroy Jerusalem but is struck with a painful disease, repents too late, writes a letter to the Jews, and dies in the mountains. The Latin moves some clauses between verses and alters the letter’s greeting and opening.
- 9:5 — The Greek calls God ‘the all-seeing Lord, the God of Israel’. The Latin agrees (“who sees all things”), but the KJV has “the Lord Almighty,” likely following a printed Greek text with a different title.
- 9:6–7 — The Greek begins 9:7 with ‘Yet he did not cease his haughtiness at all’. The Latin places this at the end of 9:6. The content is the same; only the verse division differs.
- 9:19 — The letter opens from ‘King and general Antiochus’. The KJV has “king and governor.” The Latin shown has “King Antiochus and the princes”, but the plural needs checking against a printed Clementine text, which may read the singular princeps.
Open questions
- Can a vow made in fear of death be counted as repentance?
- Why does the narrator say God would no longer have mercy on Antiochus?
2 Maccabees 10 · The temple purified and Timothy defeated
Judas purifies the temple and establishes an annual eight-day feast; under the new king Eupator the Jews fight the Idumeans and Timothy, aided by heavenly riders. The main differences concern who held the fortresses in 10:15, the heavenly riders, and the Latin’s shorter or longer account of the capture of Gazara.
- 10:15 — In the Greek and the KJV ‘the Idumeans, who held strategic fortresses, harassed the Jews’. The Clementine Latin reads “the Jews” held the fortresses and waged war, reversing who acts. This is probably an early copying error of Judaei for Idumaei.
- 10:29–30 — Five riders appear ‘leading the Jews’. The KJV says “two of them led the Jews,” and the Latin has “two of them” protect Maccabeus in 10:30. The Saints Greek does not number them; the Latin and KJV probably reflect Greek copies that speak of two of the five, placed in different verses.
- 10:36–37 — The Greek tells how others ‘took possession of the city’ and slew Timothy ‘hiding in a cistern’. The Latin lacks the capture of the city but adds two days of devastation and leaves Timothy in “a certain place.”
Disparate: Latin 10:15
Open questions
- How does the new feast relate to the Feast of Booths it imitates?
- What is the purpose of the heavenly riders in the narrative?
2 Maccabees 11 · Lysias defeated and four letters of peace
Lysias besieges Beth-zur but is routed after a heavenly horseman leads the Jews; peace follows, recorded in four letters from Lysias, the king and the Romans. Differences are mostly verse division in the Latin and the handling of names, dates and small details in the letters.
- 11:8 — A horseman in white appears ‘brandishing golden armour’. The Latin has him wearing golden armour and “brandishing a spear.” The KJV follows the Greek, “shaking his armour of gold.”
- 11:2 — Lysias plans to make Jerusalem ‘a dwelling for Greeks’. The Latin and the KJV both say “the nations” or “the Gentiles,” a broader term that loses the specific threat of Greek settlement.
- 11:11–14 — The Latin shifts clauses between 11:11 and 11:14, so that the flight of the enemy and Lysias’s sending to the Jews fall in different verses. The KJV agrees with the Latin in ending 11:13 with “he sent unto them.” The story is unchanged.
Open questions
- Why might the dates of these four letters not fit easily into one sequence?
- What does the Roman letter suggest about Judea’s relation to Rome?
2 Maccabees 12 · Campaigns, the fallen soldiers, and prayer for the dead
Judas avenges the drowning of Jews at Joppa, fights through Gilead and Idumea, and afterwards finds idol tokens on his fallen soldiers, then sends an offering to Jerusalem on their behalf. The main textual differences are in the sum of money and the wording of the closing argument about the dead (12:43–45), and in the Latin numbers and place details elsewhere.
- 12:43 — The Greek says Judas collected ‘two thousand drachmas of silver’ and sent it ‘to offer a sacrifice for sin’, ‘considering the resurrection’. The Latin gives “twelve thousand” drachmas and says the sacrifice was “for the sins of the dead.” The KJV follows the Greek sum and has “a sin offering.” The sum differs; all three present the offering as linked to resurrection hope.
- 12:44–45 — All three make the argument that praying for the dead would be ‘superfluous and foolish’ without hope of resurrection. The Greek ends with Judas’s act: ‘he made atonement for the dead, so that they might be released from their sin.’ The Latin splits this into a separate verse (12:46) phrased as a general statement, “it is a holy and beneficial thought to pray for the departed, so that they may be released from sins.” The KJV follows the Greek narrative form.
- 12:13 — The Greek describes Caspin as a city ‘strong with earthworks’. The Latin reads “enclosed by bridges,” and the KJV says Judas “went about to make a bridge” to the city. The underlying Greek word was understood by each translator in a different way.
Disparate: Latin 12:43
Open questions
- How does 12:39–45 connect the soldiers’ death with the offering Judas sends to Jerusalem?
- Why might a copyist or translator have changed the sum of money in 12:43?
Chapters 13–15
2 Maccabees 13 · Menelaus’s end and Antiochus Eupator’s campaign
Menelaus is executed in the ash tower at Beroea, Judas raids the royal camp, and Antiochus Eupator makes terms with the Jews. The differences lie mainly in numbers, the manner of Menelaus’s death, and who is left as governor in 13:24.
- 13:15 — In the night raid Judas ‘killed about two thousand men’. The Latin gives “four thousand,” and the KJV also reads “about four thousand,” so both later translations agree against the Greek printed in the Saints reading.
- 13:24 — The Greek says the king ‘left Hegemonides as governor’. The Latin has the king make Maccabeus “commander and ruler,” and the KJV says he “made him principal governor.” Read as a name, the word refers to a royal officer; read as a title, it gives the office to Judas.
- 13:4–6 — The Greek has Menelaus ‘taken to Beroea’ and pushed from a tower with ‘a revolving device’. The Latin has him killed “in that very place” and describes a sheer drop; the KJV keeps Berea and a “round instrument.”
Open questions
- Why does the writer stress that Menelaus died in ashes after sinning against the altar?
- Does it matter whether Judas or Hegemonides was given the governorship in 13:24?
2 Maccabees 14 · Alcimus, Nicanor and the death of Razis
Alcimus accuses Judas before Demetrius, Nicanor first befriends Judas and then turns on him, threatens the temple, and the elder Razis dies rather than be captured. The differences concern the reading ‘separation’ or “mingling,” a date, Nicanor’s orders, and a line added in the KJV prayer.
- 14:3 — The Greek describes Alcimus defiling himself ‘during the times of separation’. The Latin has “times of intermingling,” and the KJV “times of their mingling with the Gentiles.” Greek copies differ between the two words, which describe the same period from opposite sides.
- 14:13 — The king orders Nicanor ‘to kill Judas himself’. The Latin has “capture,” which fits the later order to send Judas in chains (14:27); the KJV has “slay,” as the Greek does.
- 14:36 — The priests pray ‘preserve this recently purified house undefiled for ever.’ The KJV adds “and stop every unrighteous mouth,” words that are not in the Greek of the Saints reading nor in the Latin.
Open questions
- How does the book present Razis’s death, and how might ancient readers have judged it?
- Why does Nicanor change from friend to enemy of Judas?
2 Maccabees 15 · Judas’s dream and the defeat of Nicanor
Nicanor plans a Sabbath attack, Judas encourages his men with a dream of Onias and Jeremiah, and Nicanor is killed; a festival is set and the author closes his book. The differences are mostly Latin expansions in the dream, small changes in the closing celebration, and a different picture of wine and water in the epilogue.
- 15:14 — Onias says of Jeremiah, ‘This is the lover of the brothers, who prayeth much for the people and the holy city’. The Latin expands this with “and of the people of Israel” and repeats “this is.” Prayer by the departed prophet for the people is already in the Greek; the KJV follows the Greek.
- 15:16 — Jeremiah gives Judas ‘this holy sword, a gift from God’. The Latin adds that it will strike the adversaries “of my people Israel,” and the KJV has “wound” for ‘shatter’.
- 15:34 — The people ‘blessed the manifested Lord toward heaven’. The Latin reads “all the heavens blessed the Lord,” making the heavens the ones who praise. The KJV keeps the people praising toward heaven.
Open questions
- What does Judas’s dream suggest about how the departed righteous were thought to relate to the living?
- Why does the author end with an apology for his writing style?
Disparate verses
Verses where at least one comparison records a major difference of meaning or consequence. The Disparate study examines the Hebrew–Greek cases in depth.
- 1:35 (Latin) — KJV “the king took many gifts, and bestowed thereof on those whom he would gratify”;
- 4:12 (Latin) — KJV ‘made them wear a hat’ keeps the Greek image.
- 8:20 (Latin) — KJV agrees with the Greek numbers;
- 10:15 (Latin) — ‘Kept the Jews occupied’;
- 12:43 (Latin) — Same: two thousand drachms, a “sin offering”, mindful of the resurrection.
Points to be checked
Small inconsistencies noticed during the research. None has been changed in the reading text.
- 2:18 — The second Latin row in the packet has an empty latin_ref; its clause should be aligned to Latin 2:18 or 2:19.
- 4:27 — Saints 4:27–28 follows a modern verse division; Latin and KJV place the Sostratus clause in 4:27.
- 8:23 — KJV text in packet ends at “leading the first band,”; KJV 1611 continues “he joined battle with Nicanor.” Check packet transcription.
- 9:20 — The Saints reading ends “placing my hope in heaven” without a main verb; the Latin and KJV have a thanksgiving clause. Check the sentence against Rahlfs–Hanhart.
- 10:32 — KJV text reads “Gawra”; KJV 1611 has “Gazara.” Check packet transcription.
- 14:8 — KJV text in packet reads “aforersaid” (for “aforesaid”); transcription typo.
- 14:9 — KJV text in packet reads “seeing knowest” (1611: “seeing thou knowest”); possible transcription slip.
- 14:22 — KJV text in packet reads “Ludas” for “Judas”; transcription typo.
- 14:24 — KJV text in packet reads “he love the man” (1611: “loved”); transcription slip.
- The Vulgate comparison page still shows “assessment open” on 0 verses, and the KJV comparison page shows “review pending” on 551. The new categories can be carried onto those pages after review.
Questions still open
The research flags these as questions for specialist review, one from each chapter.
- 2 Maccabees 1 — Why would the dating of the second letter matter for how readers understand the origin of the feast of Dedication?
- 2 Maccabees 2 — Is the Greek ‘plundered’ in 2:21 meant as an image of reversal, the few despoiling the many?
- 2 Maccabees 3 — Which reading in 3:4, market administration or lawlessness, fits the narrative better?
- 2 Maccabees 4 — Why would the Old Latin translator read the Greek hat as brothels: a misunderstanding, or a moral gloss?
- 2 Maccabees 5 — How does the future tense in the Latin of 5:20 change the narrator’s comment?
- 2 Maccabees 6 — Does Eleazar’s death read differently if he “went” rather than was “dragged” to the torture frame?
- 2 Maccabees 7 — Does 7:28 teach creation out of nothing, or creation from unformed matter?
- 2 Maccabees 8 — Why might the Latin and Greek remember the size of the Babylonian force so differently?
- 2 Maccabees 9 — Can a vow made in fear of death be counted as repentance?
- 2 Maccabees 10 — How does the new feast relate to the Feast of Booths it imitates?
- 2 Maccabees 11 — Why might the dates of these four letters not fit easily into one sequence?
- 2 Maccabees 12 — How does 12:39–45 connect the soldiers’ death with the offering Judas sends to Jerusalem?
- 2 Maccabees 13 — Why does the writer stress that Menelaus died in ashes after sinning against the altar?
- 2 Maccabees 14 — How does the book present Razis’s death, and how might ancient readers have judged it?
- 2 Maccabees 15 — What does Judas’s dream suggest about how the departed righteous were thought to relate to the living?
About this edition
Research compiled 6 October 2026 from the published reading text (checked verse by verse against the chapter pages), the Hebrew–Greek, Vulgate and KJV comparison editions, and the Disparate study. The Latin–Greek and KJV–Greek classifications are new, AI-prepared and provisional; a second, independent AI review checked every chapter note and a sample of the classifications, and its corrections are applied. This is a working study edition; independent specialist review is still pending.
Study notes by Saints.Bible · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Suggest a correction
About this reading and its sources
Bespoke Saints English
- Content available
- This chapter response, not a corpus-wide coverage count.
- Displayed scope
- 27 identified reading units in this response.
- Review
- Independent review is not certified by this disclosure. The source-count snapshot declares: Provisional editorial edition. README: "Full critical-apparatus, Göttingen and UBS6/ECM comparisons, independent Greek review, and human read-aloud review remain pending." Genesis 1–11 is the accepted benchmark.
- Publication
- Served on Saints.Bible. This does not establish acceptance of a manuscript.
Fingerprint covers identified Saints-column readings only. Retained Hebrew, Latin and King James comparison columns and Workspace quotations have separate sources; their edition revisions and review status are not certified here.
The identified chapter readings match the installed Bespoke book data after whitespace normalization.
Edition facts and counting rules · Sources and review register
Snapshot details
Family: saints-bespoke-english
Fingerprint: sha256:63f9d97dbd9d236b8c962e15343904d78e706b6e34b3e1acf01a4688844c30cb
A fingerprint identifies content; it is not a quality score or scholarly approval.
{"schema_version":1,"environment":"production","publication":{"status":"served_on_production","scope":"This rendered response only; no editorial acceptance is inferred."},"review":{"status":"not_independently_certified_by_this_module","source_declaration":"Provisional editorial edition. README: \"Full critical-apparatus, Göttingen and UBS6/ECM comparisons, independent Greek review, and human read-aloud review remain pending.\" Genesis 1–11 is the accepted benchmark."},"parity":{"reader_search_downloads":"not_established","november_12_manuscripts":"not_assumed_published"},"facts_path":"/study-guides/edition-facts/","edition_family_id":"saints-bespoke-english","label":"Bespoke Saints English","surface":"parallel","book":"2-maccabees","chapter":5,"availability":{"status":"identified_reading_units_displayed","count":27,"unit":"identified displayed reading units","scope":"This chapter response, not a corpus-wide coverage count."},"snapshot":{"id":"sha256:63f9d97dbd9d236b8c962e15343904d78e706b6e34b3e1acf01a4688844c30cb","algorithm":"sha256","basis":"saints-displayed-units-v1","normalization":"Ordered chapter keys and visible text; whitespace collapsed. Plain-reader reference labels and identified editorial-note links excluded. Markup and comparison columns excluded."},"runtime_bespoke_match":"exact_identified_chapter_units","scope_note":"Fingerprint covers identified Saints-column readings only. Retained Hebrew, Latin and King James comparison columns and Workspace quotations have separate sources; their edition revisions and review status are not certified here.","runtime_artifact":{"path":"saints-bespoke-reader/data/2-maccabees.json","sha256":"62e108bb0792fb4d413ca3edc8bc2bee644ddfff7ecb13665ce6e8ccaf6fc0dc","scope":"Installed book JSON bytes. Matching this file does not establish independent review or all-surface publication parity."}}