
1 Maccabees 5 — Latin–Greek comparison
Every source verse remains separate. Open the highlighted English comparison within each card; the five numbered layers distinguish text, Catholic teaching, named non-Catholic readings, combined classification, and origins.
Rescue and the limits of ambition
Campaigns seek to protect threatened communities and bring people to safety. The narrative also distinguishes success from the failed attempt by other commanders to win a name for themselves.
Editorial chapter exposition based on the displayed readings. Church sources below supply their stated doctrinal or interpretive scope. Classification method · Tradition and source guide · Disparate studies. Ratings are working English-comparison judgments.
Compare the actual Latin and Greek witnesses through their separate English renderings. Differences of verse division are cross-referenced; they do not establish missing content. All five classifications concern the stated comparison, not the worth of a Christian tradition.
Chapter 5
Rescue expeditions in Galilee and Gilead
Latin 5:1 · Greek 5:1Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:1] When the surrounding nations heard that the altar and sanctuary had been rebuilt as before, they became very angry.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:1] When the nations round about heard that the altar had been rebuilt and the sanctuary dedicated as before, they became exceedingly angry.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:1
When the surrounding nations heard that the altar and sanctuary had been rebuilt as before, they became very angry.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:1
When the nations round about heard that the altar had been rebuilt and the sanctuary dedicated as before, they became exceedingly angry.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:1] Et factum est, ut audierunt gentes in circuitu quia ædificatum est altare et sanctuarium sicut prius, iratæ sunt valde :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:2 · Greek 5:2Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:2] They planned to destroy the descendants of Jacob who lived among them and began to kill and persecute the people.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:2] They resolved to remove the descendants of Jacob living among them, and began killing and destroying people.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:2
They planned to destroy the descendants of Jacob who lived among them and began to kill and persecute the people.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:2
They resolved to remove the descendants of Jacob living among them, and began killing and destroying people.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:2] et cogitabant tollere genus Jacob, qui erant inter eos, et cœperunt occidere de populo, et persequi.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:3 · Greek 5:3Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:3] Judas made war on the sons of Esau in Idumea and on those in Akrabattine, because they were besieging the Israelites, and he struck them with a great blow.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:3] Judas fought against the sons of Esau in Idumea, in Akrabattene, because they were besieging Israel. He struck them a great blow, subdued them, and took their spoils.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:3
Judas made war on the sons of Esau in Idumea and on those in Akrabattine, because they were besieging the Israelites, and he struck them with a great blow.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:3
Judas fought against the sons of Esau in Idumea, in Akrabattene, because they were besieging Israel. He struck them a great blow, subdued them, and took their spoils.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:3] Et debellabat Judas filios Esau in Idumæa, et eos qui erant in Acrabathane, quia circumsedebant Israëlitas : et percussit eos plaga magna.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:4 · Greek 5:4Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:4] He remembered the wickedness of the sons of Bean, who had been a snare and a stumbling block to the people, ambushing them on the road.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:4] He remembered the evil of the sons of Baean, who had become a trap and a stumbling block for the people by ambushing them on the roads.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:4
He remembered the wickedness of the sons of Bean, who had been a snare and a stumbling block to the people, ambushing them on the road.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:4
He remembered the evil of the sons of Baean, who had become a trap and a stumbling block for the people by ambushing them on the roads.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:4] Et recordatus est malitiam filiorum Bean, qui erant populo in laqueum et in scandalum, insidiantes ei in via.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:5 · Greek 5:5Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:5] He hemmed them in within their towers, advanced against them, devoted them to destruction, and burned their towers with fire, together with everyone in them.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:5] He shut them into the towers, encamped against them, devoted them to destruction, and burned the towers with everyone inside.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:5
He hemmed them in within their towers, advanced against them, devoted them to destruction, and burned their towers with fire, together with everyone in them.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:5
He shut them into the towers, encamped against them, devoted them to destruction, and burned the towers with everyone inside.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:5] Et conclusi sunt ab eo in turribus, et applicuit ad eos, et anathematizavit eos, et incendit turres eorum igni cum omnibus qui in eis erant.
Textual & Reception Notes
ἀναθεματίζω is rendered according to the explicit destruction that follows, without making it a generic curse.
Latin 5:6 · Greek 5:6Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:6] He crossed over to the sons of Ammon and found a strong force, a numerous people, and Timothy their commander.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:6] He crossed over against the sons of Ammon and found a strong force and many people, with Timothy as their leader.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:6
He crossed over to the sons of Ammon and found a strong force, a numerous people, and Timothy their commander.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:6
He crossed over against the sons of Ammon and found a strong force and many people, with Timothy as their leader.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:6] Et transivit ad filios Ammon, et invenit manum fortem, et populum copiosum, et Timotheum ducem ipsorum :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:7 · Greek 5:7Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:7] He fought many battles with them, and they were crushed before his men, and he struck them down.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:7] He engaged them in many battles. They were crushed before him, and he struck them.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:7
He fought many battles with them, and they were crushed before his men, and he struck them down.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:7
He engaged them in many battles. They were crushed before him, and he struck them.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:7] et commisit cum eis prælia multa, et contriti sunt in conspectu eorum, et percussit eos :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:8 · Greek 5:8Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:8] He captured the city of Gazer and its daughter towns and returned to Judea.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:8] He seized Jazer and its daughter towns, then returned to Judea.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:8
He captured the city of Gazer and its daughter towns and returned to Judea.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:8
He seized Jazer and its daughter towns, then returned to Judea.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:8] et cepit Gazer civitatem et filias ejus, et reversus est in Judæam.
5:8 · Translation note. Gazer is retained here as the source’s place-name. No identification with another similarly named town is imposed.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:9 · Greek 5:9Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:9] The nations in Gilead gathered against the Israelites within their borders to destroy them, and they fled to the stronghold of Dathema.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:9] The nations in Gilead gathered against the Israelites living in their territory to destroy them, and they fled into the stronghold of Dathema.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:9
The nations in Gilead gathered against the Israelites within their borders to destroy them, and they fled to the stronghold of Dathema.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:9
The nations in Gilead gathered against the Israelites living in their territory to destroy them, and they fled into the stronghold of Dathema.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:9] Et congregatæ sunt gentes quæ sunt in Galaad adversus Israëlitas, qui erant in finibus eorum, ut tollerent eos : et fugerunt in Datheman munitionem.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:10 · Greek 5:10Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:10] They sent letters to Judas and his brothers, saying, “The surrounding nations have gathered against us to destroy us.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:10] They sent letters to Judas and his brothers, saying, “The nations around us have gathered against us to destroy us.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:10
They sent letters to Judas and his brothers, saying, “The surrounding nations have gathered against us to destroy us.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:10
They sent letters to Judas and his brothers, saying, “The nations around us have gathered against us to destroy us.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:10] Et miserunt litteras ad Judam et fratres ejus, dicentes : Congregatæ sunt adversum nos gentes per circuitum, ut nos auferant,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:11 · Greek 5:11Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:11] They are preparing to come and seize the stronghold in which we have taken refuge, and Timothy is the commander of their army.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:11] They are preparing to come and seize the stronghold into which we fled, and Timothy is leading their force.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:11
They are preparing to come and seize the stronghold in which we have taken refuge, and Timothy is the commander of their army.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:11
They are preparing to come and seize the stronghold into which we fled, and Timothy is leading their force.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:11] et parant venire, et occupare munitionem, in quam confugimus : et Timotheus est dux exercitus eorum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:12 · Greek 5:12Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:12] Now, therefore, come and rescue us from their hands, for many of us have fallen.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:12] Now, therefore, come and rescue us from their hand, because many of us have fallen.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:12
Now, therefore, come and rescue us from their hands, for many of us have fallen.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:12
Now, therefore, come and rescue us from their hand, because many of us have fallen.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:12] Nunc ergo veni, et eripe nos de manibus eorum, quia cecidit multitudo de nobis.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:13 · Greek 5:13Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:13] All our brothers in the region of Tubin have been killed. They have taken their wives and children captive and carried away their spoils, and have slain nearly a thousand men there.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:13] All our brothers in the region of Tobiah have been put to death. They have taken their wives, children, and belongings captive, and have destroyed about a thousand men there.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:13
All our brothers in the region of Tubin have been killed. They have taken their wives and children captive and carried away their spoils, and have slain nearly a thousand men there.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:13
All our brothers in the region of Tobiah have been put to death. They have taken their wives, children, and belongings captive, and have destroyed about a thousand men there.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:13] Et omnes fratres nostri, qui erant in locis Tubin, interfecti sunt : et captivas duxerunt uxores eorum, et natos, et spolia, et peremerunt illic fere mille viros.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:14 · Greek 5:14Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:14] While the letters were still being read, other messengers arrived from Galilee with their tunics torn, reporting the following:
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:14] While the letters were still being read, other messengers arrived from Galilee with torn garments, reporting similar things.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:14
While the letters were still being read, other messengers arrived from Galilee with their tunics torn, reporting the following:
Septuagint Greek · English 5:14
While the letters were still being read, other messengers arrived from Galilee with torn garments, reporting similar things.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:14] Et adhuc epistolæ legebantur, et ecce alii nuntii venerunt de Galilæa conscissis tunicis, nuntiantes secundum verba hæc :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:15 · Greek 5:15Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:15] they said that people from Ptolemais, Tyre, and Sidon had gathered against them: “All Galilee is filled with foreigners intent on destroying us.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:15] They said that people from Ptolemais, Tyre, and Sidon, and all Galilee of foreigners, had gathered against them “to consume us completely.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:15
they said that people from Ptolemais, Tyre, and Sidon had gathered against them: “All Galilee is filled with foreigners intent on destroying us.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:15
They said that people from Ptolemais, Tyre, and Sidon, and all Galilee of foreigners, had gathered against them “to consume us completely.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:15] dicentes convenisse adversum se a Ptolemaida, et Tyro, et Sidone : et repleta est omnis Galilæa alienigenis, ut nos consumant.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:16 · Greek 5:16Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:16] When Judas and the people heard these words, a great assembly gathered to consider what they should do for their brothers who were in distress and under attack from them.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:16] When Judas and the people heard these words, a great assembly gathered to deliberate what to do for their brothers who were in distress and under attack.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:16
When Judas and the people heard these words, a great assembly gathered to consider what they should do for their brothers who were in distress and under attack from them.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:16
When Judas and the people heard these words, a great assembly gathered to deliberate what to do for their brothers who were in distress and under attack.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:16] Ut audivit autem Judas et populus sermones istos, convenit ecclesia magna cogitare quid facerent fratribus suis, qui in tribulatione erant, et expugnabantur ab eis.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:17 · Greek 5:17Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:17] Judas said to his brother Simon, “Choose men for yourself and go and deliver your brothers in Galilee. My brother Jonathan and I will go to Gilead.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:17] Judas said to Simon his brother, “Choose men for yourself and go rescue your brothers in Galilee. I and Jonathan my brother will go to Gilead.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:17
Judas said to his brother Simon, “Choose men for yourself and go and deliver your brothers in Galilee. My brother Jonathan and I will go to Gilead.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:17
Judas said to Simon his brother, “Choose men for yourself and go rescue your brothers in Galilee. I and Jonathan my brother will go to Gilead.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:17] Dixitque Judas Simoni fratri suo : Elige tibi viros, et vade, et libera fratres tuos in Galilæa : ego autem et frater meus Jonathas ibimus in Galaaditim.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:18 · Greek 5:18Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:18] He left Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, leaders of the people, with the remaining army in Judea to keep guard.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:18] He left Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, a leader of the people, with the remaining force in Judea to guard it.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:18
He left Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, leaders of the people, with the remaining army in Judea to keep guard.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:18
He left Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, a leader of the people, with the remaining force in Judea to guard it.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:18] Et reliquit Josephum filium Zachariæ, et Azariam, duces populi, cum residuo exercitu in Judæa ad custodiam :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:19 · Greek 5:19Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:19] He commanded them, saying, “Take charge of this people, and do not engage in war against the nations until we return.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:19] He commanded them, saying, “Take charge of this people, and do not engage the nations in battle until we return.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:19
He commanded them, saying, “Take charge of this people, and do not engage in war against the nations until we return.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:19
He commanded them, saying, “Take charge of this people, and do not engage the nations in battle until we return.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:19] et præcepit illis, dicens : Præestote populo huic : et nolite bellum committere adversum gentes, donec revertamur.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:20 · Greek 5:20Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:20] Three thousand men were assigned to Simon to go to Galilee, and eight thousand to Judas to go to Gilead.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:20] Three thousand men were assigned to Simon to go to Galilee, and eight thousand men to Judas for Gilead.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:20
Three thousand men were assigned to Simon to go to Galilee, and eight thousand to Judas to go to Gilead.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:20
Three thousand men were assigned to Simon to go to Galilee, and eight thousand men to Judas for Gilead.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:20] Et partiti sunt Simoni viri tria millia, ut iret in Galilæam : Judæ autem octo millia in Galaaditim.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:21 · Greek 5:21Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:21] Simon went to Galilee and fought many battles with the nations. The nations were crushed before him, and he pursued them as far as the gate of
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:21] Simon went to Galilee and engaged the nations in many battles. The nations were crushed before him,
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:21
Simon went to Galilee and fought many battles with the nations. The nations were crushed before him, and he pursued them as far as the gate of
Septuagint Greek · English 5:21
Simon went to Galilee and engaged the nations in many battles. The nations were crushed before him,
Related separate cards: Latin 5:21, Latin 5:22, Greek 5:21, Greek 5:22.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:21, 5:22 · Greek 5:21, 5:22. Each verse is displayed separately.
Passage alignment. The pursuit begins in Greek 5:22 but Latin 5:21; the Latin verse boundary divides gate of from Ptolemais.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:21] Et abiit Simon in Galilæam, et commisit prælia multa cum gentibus : et contritæ sunt gentes a facie ejus, et persecutus est eos usque ad portam
5:21 · Translation note. The Clementine verse boundary falls between gate of and Ptolemais. The English preserves the continuation into 5:22 so that every source verse remains traceable.
Greek 5:21 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:22 · Greek 5:22Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:22] Ptolemais. Nearly three thousand men of the nations fell, and he took their spoils.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:22] and he pursued them to the gate of Ptolemais. About three thousand men of the nations fell, and he took their spoils.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:22
Ptolemais. Nearly three thousand men of the nations fell, and he took their spoils.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:22
and he pursued them to the gate of Ptolemais. About three thousand men of the nations fell, and he took their spoils.
Related separate cards: Latin 5:21, Latin 5:22, Greek 5:21, Greek 5:22.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:21, 5:22 · Greek 5:21, 5:22. Each verse is displayed separately.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:22] Ptolemaidis : et ceciderunt de gentibus fere tria millia virorum. Et accepit spolia eorum,
Greek 5:22 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:23 · Greek 5:23Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:23] He took those who were in Galilee and Arbatta, with their wives, children, and everything they had, and brought them into Judea with great joy.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:23] He took those from Galilee and Arbattos, with their wives, children, and everything they had, and brought them into Judea with great gladness.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:23
He took those who were in Galilee and Arbatta, with their wives, children, and everything they had, and brought them into Judea with great joy.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:23
He took those from Galilee and Arbattos, with their wives, children, and everything they had, and brought them into Judea with great gladness.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:23] et assumpsit eos qui erant in Galilæa et in Arbatis, cum uxoribus, et natis, et omnibus quæ erant illis, et adduxit in Judæam cum lætitia magna.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:24 · Greek 5:24Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:24] Judas Maccabeus and his brother Jonathan crossed the Jordan and traveled three days‘ journey through the wilderness.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:24] Judas Maccabeus and Jonathan his brother crossed the Jordan and traveled a three-day journey in the wilderness.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:24
Judas Maccabeus and his brother Jonathan crossed the Jordan and traveled three days‘ journey through the wilderness.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:24
Judas Maccabeus and Jonathan his brother crossed the Jordan and traveled a three-day journey in the wilderness.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:24] Et Judas Machabæus, et Jonathas frater ejus, transierunt Jordanem, et abierunt viam trium dierum per desertum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:25 · Greek 5:25Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:25] The Nabateans met them and received them peacefully. They told them everything that had happened to their brothers in Gilead,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:25] They met the Nabateans, who received them peacefully and recounted everything that had happened to their brothers in Gilead.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:25
The Nabateans met them and received them peacefully. They told them everything that had happened to their brothers in Gilead,
Septuagint Greek · English 5:25
They met the Nabateans, who received them peacefully and recounted everything that had happened to their brothers in Gilead.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:25] Et occurrerunt eis Nabuthæi, et susceperunt eos pacifice, et narraverunt eis omnia quæ acciderant fratribus eorum in Galaaditide,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:26 · Greek 5:26Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:26] and that many of them were trapped in Barasa, Bosor, Alima, Casphor, Mageth, and Carnaim—all great and fortified cities.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:26] Many of them had been confined in Bosora, Bosor in Alema, Chaspho, Maked, and Carnaim—all these cities were strong and large.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:26
and that many of them were trapped in Barasa, Bosor, Alima, Casphor, Mageth, and Carnaim—all great and fortified cities.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:26
Many of them had been confined in Bosora, Bosor in Alema, Chaspho, Maked, and Carnaim—all these cities were strong and large.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:26] et quia multi ex eis comprehensi sunt in Barasa, et Bosor, et in Alimis, et in Casphor, et Mageth, et Carnaim : hæ omnes civitates munitæ et magnæ.
5:26 · Translation note. Rare names such as Alima, Casphor, and Mageth follow the supplied Latin forms closely. The Latin column retains the exact inflected forms; no detailed geographical identification is asserted.
Textual & Reception Notes
The online wording Βοσορ ἐν Αλεμοις is retained in the connection “Bosor in Alema”; the relation of these place names needs further textual review.
Latin 5:27 · Greek 5:27Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:27] “They are also held captive in the other cities of Gilead. Their enemies have decided to bring the army against these cities tomorrow, capture them, and destroy them in a single day.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:27] They were also confined in the other cities of Gilead. The enemy had arranged to attack the strongholds the next day, seize them, and destroy all these people in one day.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:27
“They are also held captive in the other cities of Gilead. Their enemies have decided to bring the army against these cities tomorrow, capture them, and destroy them in a single day.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:27
They were also confined in the other cities of Gilead. The enemy had arranged to attack the strongholds the next day, seize them, and destroy all these people in one day.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:27] Sed et in ceteris civitatibus Galaaditidis tenentur comprehensi, et in crastinum constituerunt admovere exercitum civitatibus his, et comprehendere, et tollere eos in una die.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:28 · Greek 5:28Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:28] Judas and his army suddenly turned their way through the wilderness toward Bosor and seized the city. He killed every male by the edge of the sword, took all their spoils, and burned it with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:28] Judas and his army suddenly turned their route toward Bosora through the wilderness. He seized the city, killed every male with the edge of the sword, took all their spoils, and burned it with fire.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:28
Judas and his army suddenly turned their way through the wilderness toward Bosor and seized the city. He killed every male by the edge of the sword, took all their spoils, and burned it with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:28
Judas and his army suddenly turned their route toward Bosora through the wilderness. He seized the city, killed every male with the edge of the sword, took all their spoils, and burned it with fire.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:28] Et convertit Judas et exercitus ejus viam in desertum Bosor repente, et occupavit civitatem : et occidit omnem masculum in ore gladii, et accepit omnia spolia eorum, et succendit eam igni.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:29 · Greek 5:29Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:29] They arose from there by night and traveled toward the stronghold.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:29] He set out from there by night, and they traveled as far as the stronghold.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:29
They arose from there by night and traveled toward the stronghold.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:29
He set out from there by night, and they traveled as far as the stronghold.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:29] Et surrexerunt inde nocte, et ibant usque ad munitionem.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:30 · Greek 5:30Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:30] At dawn, when they raised their eyes, there was a great, unnumbered multitude carrying ladders and siege engines to capture the stronghold and defeat its people.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:30] In the morning they raised their eyes and saw a great people beyond counting, carrying ladders and siege engines to seize the stronghold and attacking its defenders.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:30
At dawn, when they raised their eyes, there was a great, unnumbered multitude carrying ladders and siege engines to capture the stronghold and defeat its people.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:30
In the morning they raised their eyes and saw a great people beyond counting, carrying ladders and siege engines to seize the stronghold and attacking its defenders.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:30] Et factum est diluculo, cum elevassent oculos suos, ecce populus multus, cujus non erat numerus, portantes scalas et machinas ut comprehenderent munitionem, et expugnarent eos.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:31 · Greek 5:31Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:31] Judas saw that the battle had begun and that the battle cry rose to heaven like a trumpet, with a great outcry from the city.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:31] Judas saw that the battle had begun and that the city’s cry rose to heaven with trumpets and a loud shout.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:31
Judas saw that the battle had begun and that the battle cry rose to heaven like a trumpet, with a great outcry from the city.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:31
Judas saw that the battle had begun and that the city’s cry rose to heaven with trumpets and a loud shout.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:31] Et vidit Judas quia cœpit bellum, et clamor belli ascendit ad cælum sicut tuba, et clamor magnus de civitate :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:32 · Greek 5:32Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:32] He said to his army, “Fight today for your brothers!”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:32] He said to the men of the force, “Fight today for our brothers!”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:32
He said to his army, “Fight today for your brothers!”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:32
He said to the men of the force, “Fight today for our brothers!”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:32] et dixit exercitui suo : Pugnate hodie pro fratribus vestris.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:33 · Greek 5:33Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:33] He came behind them in three divisions, and they sounded the trumpets and cried out in prayer.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:33] He came out behind them in three divisions. They sounded the trumpets and cried out in prayer.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:33
He came behind them in three divisions, and they sounded the trumpets and cried out in prayer.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:33
He came out behind them in three divisions. They sounded the trumpets and cried out in prayer.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:33] Et venit tribus ordinibus post eos, et exclamaverunt tubis, et clamaverunt in oratione.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:34 · Greek 5:34Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:34] Timothy’s army recognized that it was Maccabeus and fled before him. His men struck them with a great blow, and nearly eight thousand of their men fell that day.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:34] Timothy’s army recognized that it was Maccabeus and fled before him. He struck them a great blow, and about eight thousand of their men fell that day.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:34
Timothy’s army recognized that it was Maccabeus and fled before him. His men struck them with a great blow, and nearly eight thousand of their men fell that day.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:34
Timothy’s army recognized that it was Maccabeus and fled before him. He struck them a great blow, and about eight thousand of their men fell that day.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:34] Et cognoverunt castra Timothei quia Machabæus est, et refugerunt a facie ejus : et percusserunt eos plaga magna. Et ceciderunt ex eis in die illa fere octo millia virorum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:35 · Greek 5:35Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:35] Judas turned toward Mizpah, attacked it, and captured it. He killed every male in it, took its spoils, and burned it with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:35] He turned aside to Alema, attacked it, seized it, killed every male in it, took its spoils, and burned it with fire.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:35
Judas turned toward Mizpah, attacked it, and captured it. He killed every male in it, took its spoils, and burned it with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:35
He turned aside to Alema, attacked it, seized it, killed every male in it, took its spoils, and burned it with fire.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:35] Et divertit Judas in Maspha, et expugnavit, et cepit eam : et occidit omnem masculum ejus, et sumpsit spolia ejus, et succendit eam igni.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:36 · Greek 5:36Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:36] From there he went and captured Casbon, Mageth, Bosor, and the remaining cities of Gilead.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:36] He set out from there and seized Chaspho, Maked, Bosor, and the other cities of Gilead.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:36
From there he went and captured Casbon, Mageth, Bosor, and the remaining cities of Gilead.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:36
He set out from there and seized Chaspho, Maked, Bosor, and the other cities of Gilead.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:36] Inde perrexit, et cepit Casbon, et Mageth, et Bosor, et reliquas civitates Galaaditidis.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:37 · Greek 5:37Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:37] After these events Timothy gathered another army and camped opposite Raphon, across the torrent.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:37] After these events Timothy gathered another army and encamped opposite Raphon, beyond the stream.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:37
After these events Timothy gathered another army and camped opposite Raphon, across the torrent.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:37
After these events Timothy gathered another army and encamped opposite Raphon, beyond the stream.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:37] Post hæc autem verba congregavit Timotheus exercitum alium, et castra posuit contra Raphon trans torrentem.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:38 · Greek 5:38Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:38] Judas sent men to scout the army, and they reported to him, saying, “All the nations around us have gathered to him, an exceedingly great army.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:38] Judas sent men to spy out the camp. They reported to him, saying, “All the nations around us have gathered to him, a very large force.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:38
Judas sent men to scout the army, and they reported to him, saying, “All the nations around us have gathered to him, an exceedingly great army.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:38
Judas sent men to spy out the camp. They reported to him, saying, “All the nations around us have gathered to him, a very large force.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:38] Et misit Judas speculari exercitum : et renuntiaverunt ei, dicentes : Quia convenerunt ad eum omnes gentes quæ in circuitu nostro sunt, exercitus multus nimis :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:39 · Greek 5:39Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:39] They have hired Arabs to help them and have camped across the torrent, ready to come against you in battle.” Judas went to meet them.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:39] They have hired Arabs to help them and are encamped beyond the stream, ready to come against you in battle.” Judas went to meet them.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:39
They have hired Arabs to help them and have camped across the torrent, ready to come against you in battle.” Judas went to meet them.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:39
They have hired Arabs to help them and are encamped beyond the stream, ready to come against you in battle.” Judas went to meet them.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:39] et Arabas conduxerunt in auxilium sibi, et castra posuerunt trans torrentem, parati ad te venire in prælium. Et abiit Judas obviam illis.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:40 · Greek 5:40Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:40] Timothy said to the commanders of his army, “When Judas and his army approach the flowing torrent, if he crosses over to us first, we will not be able to withstand him, for he will certainly prevail against us.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:40] As Judas and his army approached the watercourse, Timothy said to his army commanders, “If he crosses over to us first, we will not be able to stand against him; he will surely prevail against us.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:40
Timothy said to the commanders of his army, “When Judas and his army approach the flowing torrent, if he crosses over to us first, we will not be able to withstand him, for he will certainly prevail against us.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:40
As Judas and his army approached the watercourse, Timothy said to his army commanders, “If he crosses over to us first, we will not be able to stand against him; he will surely prevail against us.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:40] Et ait Timotheus principibus exercitus sui : Cum appropinquaverit Judas, et exercitus ejus, ad torrentem aquæ : si transierit ad nos prior, non poterimus sustinere eum, quia potens poterit adversum nos ;
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:41 · Greek 5:41Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:41] But if he is afraid to cross and camps beyond the river, we will cross over to them and prevail against him.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:41] But if he becomes afraid and encamps beyond the river, we will cross over to him and prevail against him.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:41
But if he is afraid to cross and camps beyond the river, we will cross over to them and prevail against him.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:41
But if he becomes afraid and encamps beyond the river, we will cross over to him and prevail against him.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:41] si vero timuerit transire, et posuerit castra extra flumen, transfretamus ad eos, et poterimus adversus illum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:42 · Greek 5:42Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:42] When Judas approached the flowing torrent, he stationed the scribes of the people beside the torrent and commanded them, saying, “Do not leave a single man behind; let everyone come to battle.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:42] When Judas approached the watercourse, he stationed the officers of the people at the stream and commanded them, saying, “Do not allow anyone to encamp; let everyone come into the battle.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:42
When Judas approached the flowing torrent, he stationed the scribes of the people beside the torrent and commanded them, saying, “Do not leave a single man behind; let everyone come to battle.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:42
When Judas approached the watercourse, he stationed the officers of the people at the stream and commanded them, saying, “Do not allow anyone to encamp; let everyone come into the battle.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:42] Ut autem appropinquavit Judas ad torrentem aquæ, statuit scribas populi secus torrentem, et mandavit eis, dicens : Neminem hominem reliqueritis, sed veniant omnes in prælium.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:43 · Greek 5:43Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:43] He crossed over to them first, and all the people followed him. All the nations were crushed before them, threw away their weapons, and fled to the shrine in Carnaim.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:43] He crossed over against them first, with all the people behind him. All the nations were crushed before them; they threw away their weapons and fled to the sacred precinct of Carnaim.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:43
He crossed over to them first, and all the people followed him. All the nations were crushed before them, threw away their weapons, and fled to the shrine in Carnaim.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:43
He crossed over against them first, with all the people behind him. All the nations were crushed before them; they threw away their weapons and fled to the sacred precinct of Carnaim.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:43] Et transfretavit ad illos prior, et omnis populus post eum, et contritæ sunt omnes gentes a facie eorum, et projecerunt arma sua, et fugerunt ad fanum, quod erat in Carnaim.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:44 · Greek 5:44Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:44] He seized the city itself and burned the shrine with fire, together with everyone in it. Carnaim was subdued and could not withstand Judas.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:44] They seized the city and burned the sacred precinct with everyone inside. Carnaim was overthrown, and they could no longer stand before Judas.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:44
He seized the city itself and burned the shrine with fire, together with everyone in it. Carnaim was subdued and could not withstand Judas.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:44
They seized the city and burned the sacred precinct with everyone inside. Carnaim was overthrown, and they could no longer stand before Judas.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:44] Et occupavit ipsam civitatem, et fanum succendit igni cum omnibus qui erant in ipso : et oppressa est Carnaim, et non potuit sustinere contra faciem Judæ.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:45 · Greek 5:45Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:45] Judas gathered all the Israelites in Gilead, from the least to the greatest, with their wives and children, an exceedingly great company, to come into the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:45] Judas gathered all Israel in Gilead, from small to great, with their wives, their children, and their belongings—a very great company—to go into the land of Judah.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:45
Judas gathered all the Israelites in Gilead, from the least to the greatest, with their wives and children, an exceedingly great company, to come into the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:45
Judas gathered all Israel in Gilead, from small to great, with their wives, their children, and their belongings—a very great company—to go into the land of Judah.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:45] Et congregavit Judas universos Israëlitas, qui erant in Galaaditide, a minimo usque ad maximum, et uxores eorum, et natos, et exercitum magnum valde, ut venirent in terram Juda.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:46 · Greek 5:46Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:46] They came as far as Ephron, a great city situated at the passage, very strongly fortified. There was no turning aside from it to the right or left; the road went through its center.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:46] They came as far as Ephron. It was a large, exceedingly strong city on the road, and there was no way to turn aside from it to the right or left, but only to pass through its midst.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:46
They came as far as Ephron, a great city situated at the passage, very strongly fortified. There was no turning aside from it to the right or left; the road went through its center.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:46
They came as far as Ephron. It was a large, exceedingly strong city on the road, and there was no way to turn aside from it to the right or left, but only to pass through its midst.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:46] Et venerunt usque Ephron : et hæc civitas magna in ingressu posita, munita valde, et non erat declinare ab ea dextera vel sinistra, sed per mediam iter erat.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:47 · Greek 5:47Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:47] The people in the city shut themselves in and blocked the gates with stones. Judas sent them peaceful words,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:47] The people of the city shut them out and blocked the gates with stones.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:47
The people in the city shut themselves in and blocked the gates with stones. Judas sent them peaceful words,
Septuagint Greek · English 5:47
The people of the city shut them out and blocked the gates with stones.
Related separate cards: Latin 5:47, Latin 5:48, Greek 5:47, Greek 5:48.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:47, 5:48 · Greek 5:47, 5:48. Each verse is displayed separately.
Passage alignment. Judas sending peaceful words belongs to Greek 5:48 but Latin 5:47.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:47] Et incluserunt se qui erant in civitate, et obstruxerunt portas lapidibus : et misit ad eos Judas verbis pacificis,
Greek 5:47 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:48 · Greek 5:48Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:48] saying, “Let us pass through your land to go to our own land. No one will harm you; we will only pass through on foot.” But they would not open to them.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:48] Judas sent to them with peaceful words, saying, “We will pass through your land to go to our land. No one will harm you; we will only pass through on foot.” But they would not open to him.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:48
saying, “Let us pass through your land to go to our own land. No one will harm you; we will only pass through on foot.” But they would not open to them.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:48
Judas sent to them with peaceful words, saying, “We will pass through your land to go to our land. No one will harm you; we will only pass through on foot.” But they would not open to him.
Related separate cards: Latin 5:47, Latin 5:48, Greek 5:47, Greek 5:48.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:47, 5:48 · Greek 5:47, 5:48. Each verse is displayed separately.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:48] dicens : Transeamus per terram vestram, ut eamus in terram nostram : et nemo vobis nocebit, tantum pedibus transibimus. Et nolebant eis aperire.
Greek 5:48 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:49 · Greek 5:49Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:49] Judas ordered a proclamation in the camp that each man should advance from his own position.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:49] Judas ordered a proclamation through the company that each should encamp in the place where he was.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:49
Judas ordered a proclamation in the camp that each man should advance from his own position.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:49
Judas ordered a proclamation through the company that each should encamp in the place where he was.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:49] Et præcepit Judas prædicare in castris, ut applicarent unusquisque in quo erat loco :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:50 · Greek 5:50Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:50] The mighty men advanced, and he attacked that city all day and all night, and the city was delivered into his hand.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:50] The men of the force encamped. He attacked the city all that day and all that night, and the city was given into his hand.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:50
The mighty men advanced, and he attacked that city all day and all night, and the city was delivered into his hand.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:50
The men of the force encamped. He attacked the city all that day and all that night, and the city was given into his hand.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:50] et applicuerunt se viri virtutis, et oppugnavit civitatem illam tota die et tota nocte, et tradita est civitas in manu ejus :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:51 · Greek 5:51Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:51] They slew every male by the edge of the sword. He uprooted the city and took its spoils, and passed through the whole city over the slain.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:51] He destroyed every male with the edge of the sword, uprooted the city, took its spoils, and passed through the city over the slain.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:51
They slew every male by the edge of the sword. He uprooted the city and took its spoils, and passed through the whole city over the slain.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:51
He destroyed every male with the edge of the sword, uprooted the city, took its spoils, and passed through the city over the slain.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:51] et peremerunt omnem masculum in ore gladii, et eradicavit eam, et accepit spolia ejus : et transivit per totam civitatem super interfectos.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:52 · Greek 5:52Same
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:52] They crossed the Jordan into the great plain, opposite Beth-shan.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:52] They crossed the Jordan into the great plain opposite Beth-shan.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Same. The displayed English wording agrees after punctuation and capitalization are set aside. This does not assert that the Latin and Greek have identical grammar.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:52
They crossed the Jordan into the great plain, opposite Beth-shan.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:52
They crossed the Jordan into the great plain opposite Beth-shan.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Same. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: No difference of displayed wording needs a textual origin here. Agreement in English does not settle the history of the underlying witnesses. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:52] Et transgressi sunt Jordanem in campo magno, contra faciem Bethsan.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:53 · Greek 5:53Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:53] Judas gathered the stragglers and encouraged the people along the whole road until they came into the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:53] Judas gathered those who lagged behind and encouraged the people along the whole road until he came into the land of Judah.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:53
Judas gathered the stragglers and encouraged the people along the whole road until they came into the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:53
Judas gathered those who lagged behind and encouraged the people along the whole road until he came into the land of Judah.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:53] Et erat Judas congregans extremos, et exhortabatur populum per totam viam, donec venirent in terram Juda :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:54 · Greek 5:54Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:54] They went up to Mount Zion with joy and gladness and offered burnt offerings, because not one of them had fallen before they returned in peace.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:54] They went up to Mount Zion with gladness and joy and presented whole burnt offerings, because none of them had fallen before they returned in peace.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:54
They went up to Mount Zion with joy and gladness and offered burnt offerings, because not one of them had fallen before they returned in peace.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:54
They went up to Mount Zion with gladness and joy and presented whole burnt offerings, because none of them had fallen before they returned in peace.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:54] et ascenderunt in montem Sion cum lætitia, et gaudio, et obtulerunt holocausta, quod nemo ex eis cecidisset donec reverterentur in pace.
Textual & Reception Notes
The claim concerns this returning company as narrated; it is not a claim that no Israelite died anywhere during the campaigns.
Latin 5:55 · Greek 5:55Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:55] In the days when Judas and Jonathan were in the land of Gilead, and his brother Simon was in Galilee opposite Ptolemais,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:55] In the days when Judas and Jonathan were in the land of Gilead, and Simon his brother was in Galilee opposite Ptolemais,
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:55
In the days when Judas and Jonathan were in the land of Gilead, and his brother Simon was in Galilee opposite Ptolemais,
Septuagint Greek · English 5:55
In the days when Judas and Jonathan were in the land of Gilead, and Simon his brother was in Galilee opposite Ptolemais,
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:55] Et in diebus quibus erat Judas et Jonathas in terra Galaad, et Simon frater ejus in Galilæa contra faciem Ptolemaidis,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:56 · Greek 5:56Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:56] Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, commander of the force, heard of their successes and the battles that had taken place.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:56] Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, commanders of the force, heard of their brave deeds and the warfare they had carried out.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:56
Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, commander of the force, heard of their successes and the battles that had taken place.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:56
Joseph son of Zechariah and Azariah, commanders of the force, heard of their brave deeds and the warfare they had carried out.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:56] audivit Josephus Zachariæ filius, et Azarias princeps virtutis, res bene gestas, et prælia quæ facta sunt,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:57 · Greek 5:57Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:57] He said, “Let us also make a name for ourselves and go to fight the nations around us.”
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:57] They said, “Let us also make a name for ourselves. Let us go and fight the nations around us.”
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:57
He said, “Let us also make a name for ourselves and go to fight the nations around us.”
Septuagint Greek · English 5:57
They said, “Let us also make a name for ourselves. Let us go and fight the nations around us.”
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:57] et dixit : Faciamus et ipsi nobis nomen, et eamus pugnare adversus gentes quæ in circuitu nostro sunt.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:58 · Greek 5:58Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:58] He gave orders to those in his army, and they went to Jamnia.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:58] They gave orders to the men of the force with them, and they marched against Jamnia.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:58
He gave orders to those in his army, and they went to Jamnia.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:58
They gave orders to the men of the force with them, and they marched against Jamnia.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:58] Et præcepit his qui erant in exercitu suo, et abierunt Jamniam.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:59 · Greek 5:59Same
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:59] Gorgias and his men came out of the city to meet them in battle.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:59] Gorgias and his men came out of the city to meet them in battle.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Same. The displayed English wording agrees after punctuation and capitalization are set aside. This does not assert that the Latin and Greek have identical grammar.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:59
Gorgias and his men came out of the city to meet them in battle.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:59
Gorgias and his men came out of the city to meet them in battle.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Same. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: No difference of displayed wording needs a textual origin here. Agreement in English does not settle the history of the underlying witnesses. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:59] Et exivit Gorgias de civitate, et viri ejus obviam illis in pugnam.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:60 · Greek 5:60Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:60] Joseph and Azariah were put to flight as far as the borders of Judea. About two thousand men of the people of Israel fell that day, and there was a great rout among the people,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:60] Joseph and Azariah were routed and pursued to the borders of Judea. About two thousand men of the people of Israel fell that day.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:60
Joseph and Azariah were put to flight as far as the borders of Judea. About two thousand men of the people of Israel fell that day, and there was a great rout among the people,
Septuagint Greek · English 5:60
Joseph and Azariah were routed and pursued to the borders of Judea. About two thousand men of the people of Israel fell that day.
Related separate cards: Latin 5:60, Latin 5:61, Greek 5:60, Greek 5:61.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:60, 5:61 · Greek 5:60, 5:61. Each verse is displayed separately.
Passage alignment. The statement of a great rout belongs to Greek 5:61 but Latin 5:60.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:60] Et fugati sunt Josephus et Azarias usque in fines Judææ : et ceciderunt illo die de populo Israël ad duo millia viri, et facta est fuga magna in populo :
Greek 5:60 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:61 · Greek 5:61Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:61] because they had not listened to Judas and his brothers, thinking they would act valiantly.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:61] A great rout occurred among the people because they had not listened to Judas and his brothers, thinking to perform brave deeds.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:61
because they had not listened to Judas and his brothers, thinking they would act valiantly.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:61
A great rout occurred among the people because they had not listened to Judas and his brothers, thinking to perform brave deeds.
Related separate cards: Latin 5:60, Latin 5:61, Greek 5:60, Greek 5:61.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 5:60, 5:61 · Greek 5:60, 5:61. Each verse is displayed separately.
Latin source and translation notes
[5:61] quia non audierunt Judam, et fratres ejus, existimantes fortiter se facturos.
Greek 5:61 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:62 · Greek 5:62Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:62] But they were not of the stock of those men through whom deliverance came to Israel.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:62] But they were not of the line of those men through whose hand the deliverance of Israel had been granted.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:62
But they were not of the stock of those men through whom deliverance came to Israel.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:62
But they were not of the line of those men through whose hand the deliverance of Israel had been granted.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:62] Ipsi autem non erant de semine virorum illorum, per quos salus facta est in Israël.
Textual & Reception Notes
The narrator makes a claim about the chosen family; this is retained as a narrative assertion.
Latin 5:63 · Greek 5:63Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:63] The men of Judah were greatly honored in the sight of all Israel and all the nations wherever their name was heard.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:63] The man Judas and his brothers were greatly honored before all Israel and all the nations wherever their name was heard.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin honors the men of Judah; Greek names Judas and his brothers. The collective receiving honor is framed differently.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:63
The men of Judah were greatly honored in the sight of all Israel and all the nations wherever their name was heard.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:63
The man Judas and his brothers were greatly honored before all Israel and all the nations wherever their name was heard.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:63] Et viri Juda magnificati sunt valde in conspectu omnis Israël, et gentium omnium ubi audiebatur nomen eorum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:64 · Greek 5:64Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:64] People gathered to them, acclaiming their success.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:64] People gathered to them, acclaiming them.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:64
People gathered to them, acclaiming their success.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:64
People gathered to them, acclaiming them.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:64] Et convenerunt ad eos fausta acclamantes.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:65 · Greek 5:65Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:65] Judas and his brothers went out and attacked the sons of Esau in the land to the south. He struck Hebron and its daughter towns and burned its walls and surrounding towers with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:65] Judas and his brothers went out and fought the sons of Esau in the southern land. He struck Hebron and its daughter towns, demolished its fortifications, and burned its towers all around.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:65
Judas and his brothers went out and attacked the sons of Esau in the land to the south. He struck Hebron and its daughter towns and burned its walls and surrounding towers with fire.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:65
Judas and his brothers went out and fought the sons of Esau in the southern land. He struck Hebron and its daughter towns, demolished its fortifications, and burned its towers all around.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:65] Et exivit Judas et fratres ejus, et expugnabant filios Esau in terra quæ ad austrum est, et percussit Chebron et filias ejus : et muros ejus, et turres succendit igni in circuitu.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:66 · Greek 5:66Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:66] He broke camp to go into the land of the foreigners and traveled through Samaria.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:66] He set out to go into the land of foreigners and passed through Marisa.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The route passes through Samaria in the Latin rendering and Marisa in the Greek. These are distinct place designations, not an English spelling variant.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:66
He broke camp to go into the land of the foreigners and traveled through Samaria.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:66
He set out to go into the land of foreigners and passed through Marisa.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:66] Et movit castra ut iret in terram alienigenarum, et perambulabat Samariam.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:67 · Greek 5:67Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:67] On that day priests fell in battle while seeking to act valiantly, going out to battle without counsel.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:67] That day priests fell in battle because they wished to perform brave deeds and went out to battle without counsel.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:67
On that day priests fell in battle while seeking to act valiantly, going out to battle without counsel.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:67
That day priests fell in battle because they wished to perform brave deeds and went out to battle without counsel.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:67] In die illa ceciderunt sacerdotes in bello, dum volunt fortiter facere, dum sine consilio exeunt in prælium.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 5:68 · Greek 5:68Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[5:68] Judas turned aside to Azotus in the land of the foreigners, tore down their altars, and burned the carved images of their gods with fire. He took the spoils of the cities and returned to the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[5:68] Judas turned aside to Azotus in the land of foreigners, pulled down their pagan altars, burned the carved images of their gods with fire, took the spoils of the cities, and returned to the land of Judah.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows the changed English expressions in their complete verse context. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 5:68
Judas turned aside to Azotus in the land of the foreigners, tore down their altars, and burned the carved images of their gods with fire. He took the spoils of the cities and returned to the land of Judah.
Septuagint Greek · English 5:68
Judas turned aside to Azotus in the land of foreigners, pulled down their pagan altars, burned the carved images of their gods with fire, took the spoils of the cities, and returned to the land of Judah.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 1 Maccabees 5; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Contextual ethical lens. CCC 2263–2265 treats defense of life under moral limits. This offers a framework for examining the violence narrated here, not an official judgment that each Maccabean action was justified. Keep the chapter context, rescue and the limits of ambition, in view.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[5:68] Et declinavit Judas in Azotum in terram alienigenarum, et diruit aras eorum, et sculptilia deorum ipsorum succendit igni : et cepit spolia civitatum, et reversus est in terram Juda.
Textual & Reception Notes