Find & study this chapter
Look closer
Notice a repeated word. Compare a reading. Keep a question for your next study.
Explore The King’s Bible · External KJV resources, opening in a new tab.
1 Maccabees — Parallel Reader
Study Notes for 1 Maccabees 8 · Chapter summaries, translation research and open questions.

1 Maccabees · 3 English readings
1 Maccabees 8
Read this passage across the published editions. Choose the translations you want to see.
About the texts and verse alignment
Bespoke Saints English is the reading edition. Study Workspace research and quotations use the existing comparison sources. The other columns show the English readings available in this book’s existing comparison studies. Follow a source link beside any reading to open its original study and source assessment.
Rows follow this book’s published reading and comparison references. Original source references remain beside each reading, including grouped verses and different numbering. A missing match is labelled; another translation is never substituted for it. The source studies’ review and numbering limits still apply.
On a small screen, swipe the table sideways or hide columns.
| Verse | Bespoke Saints EnglishGreek–English | Latin–EnglishClementine Vulgate · English rendering | King JamesKing James Version · Apocrypha |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8:1 | 8:1 ↗ Judas heard the reputation of the Romans: that they were mighty in strength, that they looked favourably on all who joined them, that they established friendship with whoever approached them, and that they were mighty in strength. | 8:1 ↗ Judas heard the reputation of the Romans: that they were mighty in strength, consented to all that was asked of them, and established friendship with all who approached them; and that they were mighty in strength. | KJV 8:1 ↗ Now Judas had heard of the Romans, that they were mighty and valiant men, and such as would lovingly accept all that joined themselves unto them, and make a league of amity with all that came unto them; |
| 8:2 | 8:2 ↗ They recounted to him their wars, the brave deeds they were doing among the Galatians, and how they had subdued them and brought them under tribute; | 8:2 ↗ They heard of their battles and the brave deeds they had done in Galatia, how they had conquered them and brought them under tribute; | KJV 8:2 ↗ And that they were men of great valour. It was told him also of their wars and noble acts which they had done among the Galatians, and how they had conquered them, and brought them under tribute; |
| 8:3 | 8:3 ↗ also what they had done in the country of Spain to gain control of the silver and gold mines there. | 8:3 ↗ what great things they had done in the region of Spain, how they had brought its silver and gold mines under their power and had gained possession of the whole place through their planning and perseverance; | KJV 8:3 ↗ And what they had done in the country of Spain, for the winning of the mines of the silver and gold which is there; |
| 8:4 | 8:4 ↗ By their counsel and perseverance they had gained control of the whole region, although it was very far from them. They had also overcome the kings who came against them from the end of the earth, crushing them and striking them a great blow; the survivors paid them tribute every year. | 8:4 ↗ and how they had crushed places very far from them and kings who had come against them from the ends of the earth, striking them with a great blow, while the others paid them tribute every year. | KJV 8:4 ↗ And that by their policy and patience they had conquered all the place, though it were very far from them; and the kings also that came against them from the uttermost part of the earth, till they had discomfited them, and given them a great overthrow, so that the rest did give them tribute every year: |
| 8:5 | 8:5 ↗ They had crushed in battle Philip, Perseus king of the Kittians, and those who rose against them, and had subdued them. | 8:5 ↗ They had crushed Philip, Perseus king of the Kittim, and the others who had taken up arms against them in war, and had conquered them. | KJV 8:5 ↗ Beside this, how they had discomfited in battle Philip, and Perseus, king of the Citims, with others that lifted up themselves against them, and had overcome them: |
| 8:6 | 8:6 ↗ Antiochus the Great, king of Asia, had marched against them for battle with a hundred and twenty elephants, cavalry, chariots, and an exceedingly large force, but he was crushed by them. | 8:6 ↗ Antiochus the Great, king of Asia, who had made war upon them with a hundred twenty elephants, cavalry, chariots, and an exceedingly great army, had been crushed by them. | KJV 8:6 ↗ How also Antiochus the great king of Asia, that came against them in battle, having an hundred and twenty elephants, with horsemen, and chariots, and a very great army, was discomfited by them; |
| 8:7 | 8:7 ↗ They took him alive and required him and those reigning after him to pay a great tribute, give hostages, and make a territorial settlement, | 8:7 ↗ They had captured him alive and imposed upon him and those who would reign after him the payment of great tribute, the giving of hostages and a fixed payment, | KJV 8:7 ↗ And how they took him alive, and covenanted that he and such as reigned after him should pay a great tribute, and give hostages, and that which was agreed upon, |
| 8:8 | 8:8 ↗ including the country of India, Media, and Lydia, some of their finest regions. They took them from him and gave them to King Eumenes. | 8:8 ↗ and the surrender of the region of the Indians, the Medes, and the Lydians, among their best regions. Having received these from them, they gave them to King Eumenes. | KJV 8:8 ↗ And the country of India, and Media and Lydia and of the goodliest countries, which they took of him, and gave to king Eumenes: |
| 8:9 | 8:9 ↗ They also heard that the people of Greece had resolved to come and destroy them. | 8:9 ↗ Those in Hellas had wanted to go and destroy them, but the matter became known to the Romans. | KJV 8:9 ↗ Moreover how the Grecians had determined to come and destroy them; |
| 8:10 | 8:10 ↗ The Romans learned the plan and sent one general against them. They fought them, and many fell wounded; they took their wives and children captive, plundered them, subdued their land, demolished their strongholds, and enslaved them to this day. | 8:10 ↗ They sent a single commander against them and fought against them. Many of them fell; they took their wives and children captive, plundered them, possessed their land, tore down their walls, and reduced them to slavery to this day. | KJV 8:10 ↗ And that they, having knowledge thereof sent against them a certain captain, and fighting with them slew many of them, and carried away captives their wives and their children, and spoiled them, and took possession of their lands, and pulled down their strong holds, and brought them to be their servants unto this day: |
| 8:11 | 8:11 ↗ The remaining kingdoms and islands, as many as ever resisted them, they destroyed and enslaved. But with their friends and those who relied on them they maintained friendship. | 8:11 ↗ They had devastated the remaining kingdoms and islands that had ever resisted them and brought them under their power. | KJV 8:11 ↗ It was told him besides, how they destroyed and brought under their dominion all other kingdoms and isles that at any time resisted them; |
| 8:12 | 8:12 ↗ They subdued kings near and far, and all who heard their name feared them. | 8:12 ↗ But with their friends and those who found security in them, they maintained friendship. They conquered kingdoms near and far, for all who heard their name feared them. | KJV 8:12 ↗ But with their friends and such as relied upon them they kept amity: and that they had conquered kingdoms both far and nigh, insomuch as all that heard of their name were afraid of them: |
| 8:13 | 8:13 ↗ Those whom they wish to help and to have as kings do reign; those whom they wish to remove, they remove. They have been greatly exalted. | 8:13 ↗ Those whom they wished to help become kings became kings, and those whom they wished they cast down from kingship. They were greatly exalted. | KJV 8:13 ↗ Also that, whom they would help to a kingdom, those reign; and whom again they would, they displace: finally, that they were greatly exalted: |
| 8:14 | 8:14 ↗ Yet in all these things not one of them has put on a diadem or clothed himself in purple to magnify himself by it. | 8:14 ↗ Yet in all this no one wore a diadem or clothed himself in purple to be magnified by it. | KJV 8:14 ↗ Yet for all this none of them wore a crown or was clothed in purple, to be magnified thereby: |
| 8:15 | 8:15 ↗ They made a council chamber for themselves, and every day three hundred and twenty men deliberated, continually taking counsel concerning the people so that they might be well ordered. | 8:15 ↗ They had established a senate for themselves, and every day they consulted three hundred twenty men who were always taking counsel for the multitude, to carry out worthy measures. | KJV 8:15 ↗ Moreover how they had made for themselves a senate house, wherein three hundred and twenty men sat in council daily, consulting alway for the people, to the end they might be well ordered: |
| 8:16 | 8:16 ↗ Each year they entrust one man to rule them and govern their whole land. All obey the one, and there is no envy or rivalry among them. | 8:16 ↗ Each year they entrusted their governing authority to one man to rule their whole land. Everyone obeyed this one man, and there was no envy or jealousy among them. | KJV 8:16 ↗ And that they committed their government to one man every year, who ruled over all their country, and that all were obedient to that one, and that there was neither envy nor emmulation among them. |
| 8:17 | 8:17 ↗ Judas chose Eupolemus son of John son of Accos, and Jason son of Eleazar, and sent them to Rome to establish friendship and an alliance | 8:17 ↗ Judas chose Eupolemus son of John, son of Jacob, and Jason son of Eleazar, and sent them to Rome to establish friendship and alliance with them, | KJV 8:17 ↗ In consideration of these things, Judas chose Eupolemus the son of John, the son of Accos, and Jason the son of Eleazar, and sent them to Rome, to make a league of amity and confederacy with them, |
| 8:18 | 8:18 ↗ and to remove the yoke from them, because they saw the kingdom of the Greeks enslaving Israel in servitude. | 8:18 ↗ and to remove from themselves the yoke of the Greeks, because they saw that they were pressing the kingdom of Israel into slavery. | KJV 8:18 ↗ And to intreat them that they would take the yoke from them; for they saw that the kingdom of the Grecians did oppress Israel with servitude. |
| 8:19 | 8:19 ↗ They went to Rome, a very long journey, entered the council chamber, and spoke, saying, | 8:19 ↗ They traveled a very long journey to Rome, entered the senate, and said, | KJV 8:19 ↗ They went therefore to Rome, which was a very great journey, and came into the senate, where they spake and said. |
| 8:20 | 8:20 ↗ “Judas, also called Maccabeus, his brothers, and the people of the Jews have sent us to you to establish an alliance and peace with you, and to have us enrolled as your allies and friends.” | 8:20 ↗ “Judas Maccabeus, his brothers, and the people of the Jews have sent us to you to establish alliance and peace with you, and to enroll us as your allies and friends.” | KJV 8:20 ↗ Judas Maccabeus with his brethren, and the people of the Jews, have sent us unto you, to make a confederacy and peace with you, and that we might be registered your confederates and friends. |
| 8:21 | 8:21 ↗ The proposal pleased them. | 8:21 ↗ The proposal pleased them. | KJV 8:21 ↗ So that matter pleased the Romans well. |
| 8:22 | 8:22 ↗ This is the copy of the letter they inscribed on bronze tablets and sent to Jerusalem to remain there with them as a memorial of peace and alliance: | 8:22 ↗ This is the reply they inscribed on bronze tablets and sent to Jerusalem, to remain with them there as a memorial of peace and alliance: | KJV 8:22 ↗ And this is the copy of the epistle which the senate wrote back again in tables of brass, and sent to Jerusalem, that there they might have by them a memorial of peace and confederacy: |
| 8:23 | 8:23 ↗ “May it be well with the Romans and the nation of the Jews on sea and on dry land for ever, and may sword and enemy be far from them. | 8:23 ↗ “May it be well with the Romans and the nation of the Jews at sea and on land forever, and may sword and enemy be far from them. | KJV 8:23 ↗ Good success be to the Romans, and to the people of the Jews, by sea and by land for ever: the sword also and enemy be far from them, |
| 8:24 | 8:24 ↗ If war comes first upon Rome or upon any of their allies throughout their whole dominion, | 8:24 ↗ If war comes first upon the Romans or upon any of their allies throughout their dominion, | KJV 8:24 ↗ If there come first any war upon the Romans or any of their confederates throughout all their dominion, |
| 8:25 | 8:25 ↗ the nation of the Jews shall fight alongside them wholeheartedly, as circumstances prescribe for them. | 8:25 ↗ the nation of the Jews shall give help wholeheartedly, as circumstances dictate. | KJV 8:25 ↗ The people of the Jews shall help them, as the time shall be appointed, with all their heart: |
| 8:26 | 8:26 ↗ They shall neither give nor supply grain, weapons, money, or ships to those making war, as Rome has decided. They shall keep their obligations, receiving nothing. | 8:26 ↗ They shall neither give nor supply those fighting against them with grain, arms, money, or ships, as has seemed good to the Romans. They shall keep their obligations, receiving nothing from them. | KJV 8:26 ↗ Neither shall they give any thing unto them that make war upon them, or aid them with victuals, weapons, money, or ships, as it hath seemed good unto the Romans; but they shall keep their covenants without taking any thing therefore. |
| 8:27 | 8:27 ↗ Likewise, if war comes first upon the nation of the Jews, the Romans shall fight alongside them with all their soul, as circumstances prescribe for them. | 8:27 ↗ Likewise, if war comes first upon the nation of the Jews, the Romans shall help them sincerely, as circumstances permit. | KJV 8:27 ↗ In the same manner also, if war come first upon the nation of the Jews, the Romans shall help them with all their heart, according as the time shall be appointed them: |
| 8:28 | 8:28 ↗ To those acting as allies, grain, weapons, money, and ships shall not be given, as Rome has decided. They shall keep these obligations without deceit. | 8:28 ↗ Those giving aid shall not be given grain, arms, money, or ships, as has seemed good to the Romans, and they shall keep their obligations without deceit. | KJV 8:28 ↗ Neither shall victuals be given to them that take part against them, or weapons, or money, or ships, as it hath seemed good to the Romans; but they shall keep their covenants, and that without deceit. |
| 8:29 | 8:29 ↗ On these terms the Romans thus established an agreement with the Jewish people. | 8:29 ↗ On these terms the Romans have made an agreement with the people of the Jews. | KJV 8:29 ↗ According to these articles did the Romans make a covenant with the people of the Jews. |
| 8:30 | 8:30 ↗ If after these terms both parties decide to add or remove anything, they shall do so by their own choice; whatever they add or remove shall be binding. | 8:30 ↗ If after these terms either party wishes to add something to them or remove something from them, they shall do so by their decision, and whatever they add or remove shall be binding. | KJV 8:30 ↗ Howbeit if hereafter the one party or the other shall think to meet to add or diminish any thing, they may do it at their pleasures, and whatsoever they shall add or take away shall be ratified. |
| 8:31 | 8:31 ↗ Concerning the evils that King Demetrius is committing against them, we have written to him, saying, ‘Why have you made your yoke heavy upon our friends and allies, the Jews? | 8:31 ↗ Concerning the evils that King Demetrius has done to them, we have written to him, saying, ‘Why have you made your yoke heavy upon our friends and allies, the Jews? | KJV 8:31 ↗ And as touching the evils that Demetrius doeth to the Jews, we have written unto him, saying, Wherefore thou made thy yoke heavy upon our friends and confederates the Jews? |
| 8:32 | 8:32 ↗ If, therefore, they appeal against you again, we will give judgment for them and make war on you by sea and by land.’” | 8:32 ↗ If, therefore, they appeal to us again, we shall uphold their cause against you and make war upon you by sea and land.’” | KJV 8:32 ↗ If therefore they complain any more against thee, we will do them justice, and fight with thee by sea and by land. |
Study Notes — 1 Maccabees
Chapter summaries, translation choices, historical interpretation and questions for further study.
Saints Translation · Study edition
1 Maccabees — Study Edition
Verse-by-verse research on the Saints Translation of 1 Maccabees, condensed: where the Greek, the Latin Vulgate and the King James Bible differ, why the differences arose, and how Jewish and Christian readers have understood the text.
About this study
This page condenses the verse-by-verse research behind the Saints English translation of 1 Maccabees, made from the Greek Septuagint in the Rahlfs–Hanhart edition (2006). The book has come down in Greek, so there is no Masoretic Hebrew text; every verse is compared with the Latin Vulgate (the Clementine text) and with the King James Version, which printed 1 Maccabees among its Apocrypha. Each comparison records the difference in wording, how Catholic and Protestant readers explain the passage, how the saints and early Christian writers read it, a combined classification, and how the difference arose.
This is working research, not a finished critical edition. The Latin–Greek categories come from the project’s comparison edition and were checked on 6 October 2026, with a few changed; the KJV–Greek categories are new on that date (the KJV comparison page still says “classification pending”). These judgements were made by AI from the published texts and notes and await specialist review. No manuscripts or critical apparatus have been consulted directly.
Please note: Saints English is literal-poetic: accurate to the Greek, with the cadence of older English (“thou”, “hath”). The comparison pages still show an earlier modern-English draft of the Greek in their Greek column, so their wording can differ from the reading text; the reading text is authoritative.
How to read the notes
- Two comparisons stand behind every verse. Latin ↔ Greek sets the Vulgate beside the Septuagint, with Catholic and wider Christian reception. KJV ↔ Greek sets the King James Apocrypha beside the Greek, with Protestant commentary and the saints. There is no Hebrew text of this book to compare.
- Five categories describe each relationship: Same, Similar (a modest difference of expression), Different (a name, number, action or image), Divergent (material added, absent or rearranged) and Disparate (a major difference of meaning or consequence). They describe texts, not the standing of any tradition.
- Both the Old Latin and the KJV were translated from Greek, so most of their differences from the Saints reading come from other Greek manuscripts or printed editions, or from the translators’ own wording.
- Keep apart the narrator, a character speaking in the story, a later commentator, and this project’s own analysis. A difference is recorded without assuming what caused it.
Chapter and verse numbering
- Chapter and verse numbers follow the Greek; 1 Maccabees here has 924 verses. The book has come down in Greek, so there is no Masoretic Hebrew text to compare, and the Hebrew–Greek comparison does not apply.
- The Latin of 1 Maccabees in the Vulgate is an Old Latin translation made from Greek, not a translation by Jerome. Its Latin–Greek categories were already assigned by the project’s comparison edition; this study checks them and changes a few, each with its reason.
- The 1611 King James Bible printed 1 Maccabees among its Apocrypha, translated from Greek. In places the Latin or the KJV follows a Greek manuscript reading that the modern critical text corrects, for example Gaza for Gazara at 13:43. From 13:52 the Latin verse numbers run one ahead of the Greek.
Jump to a chapter
The two comparisons at a glance
Counts are per verse of the Greek (924 verse units). Every verse has a Latin counterpart. The Latin and KJV columns are new and provisional.
| Category | Latin ↔ Greek | KJV ↔ Greek |
|---|---|---|
| Same | 35 | 614 |
| Similar | 691 | 264 |
| Different | 138 | 31 |
| Divergent | 57 | 12 |
| Disparate | 3 | 3 |
| Total | 924 | 924 |
The full verse-by-verse record, with every source, is kept in the research file for 1 Maccabees.
Chapter by chapter
Chapters 1–4
1 Maccabees 1 · Antiochus Epiphanes and the desolation of the temple
Alexander’s empire breaks up, Antiochus Epiphanes plunders the Jerusalem temple, and a royal decree forbids Jewish worship on pain of death. Most differences come from the Clementine Latin, an Old Latin translation made from the Greek, which divides several verses differently and paraphrases; the KJV, translated from the Greek, stays close.
- 1:1 — The Greek says Alexander defeated Darius and ‘he became king in his place, having first ruled over Greece.’ The Latin drops the succession clause and keeps only that he “first reigned in Greece”. The KJV keeps both (“reigned in his stead”). The opening line frames Alexander as heir of the Persian empire.
- 1:21–1:24 — The list of temple treasures runs across these verses. The Latin numbers them differently: its 1:21 holds the whole inventory and ends “he broke everything to pieces” where the Greek says ‘He stripped everything off.’ The Latin also has “little golden mortars” for the Greek ‘golden censers’. The KJV follows the Greek order.
- 1:9 — In the Greek the successor kings themselves ‘multiplied evils on the earth.’ The Latin and the KJV both put it passively (“evils were multiplied”), so the blame is less directly on the rulers.
Open questions
- Why might the Old Latin translator have regrouped the temple inventory and the decree into different verses?
- Does the plural “they set up” in 1:54 point to a different Greek text behind the KJV than the Saints reading follows?
1 Maccabees 2 · Mattathias refuses to sacrifice and begins the revolt
Mattathias, a priest at Modein, refuses the king’s order to sacrifice, kills the apostate and the royal officer, and leads the faithful into the hills; before dying he charges his sons with the law. The main differences are again in the Latin, which changes who is mourned in 2:9 and paraphrases several speeches; the KJV agrees with the Greek almost throughout.
- 2:9 — Mattathias laments that ‘her little children were slain in her squares’. The Latin has “her elders have been slaughtered in the streets”, a different group of victims. The KJV agrees with the Greek (“her infants are slain”). The Latin may reflect a misread Greek word or a different copy.
- 2:16 — The Greek reads ‘Many from Israel came to them, and Mattathias and his sons gathered.’ The Latin turns the scene into a contrast: many “agreed”, but Mattathias and his sons “stood firm”. The KJV follows the Greek (“came together”).
- 2:21–2:22 — The Greek idiom ‘Far be it from us’ becomes in the Latin “May God be gracious to us! It is not good”, and the Latin adds “nor will we sacrifice”. The KJV renders the idiom as “God forbid”. The Latin turns Mattathias’s refusal into a prayer as well as a vow.
Disparate: Latin 2:9
Open questions
- How does the Latin “stood firm” in 2:16 change the picture of Mattathias at the start of the revolt?
- Why does Mattathias’s list of ancestors in 2:52-60 stress zeal and faithfulness under trial?
1 Maccabees 3 · Judas takes command and Israel gathers at Mizpah
Judas Maccabeus succeeds his father, defeats Apollonius and Seron, and faces the large army that Lysias sends while Antiochus goes east. The main differences lie in how the Old Latin (the early Latin translation kept in the Vulgate) and the KJV supply God’s name where the Greek says ‘Heaven’, and in the obscure account of the law book at Mizpah.
- 3:48 — The Greek says Israel ‘unrolled the book of the law concerning the matters for which the nations consulted the likenesses of their idols’: they sought God’s word where pagans sought idols. The Latin follows the Greek wording closely (“about which the nations searched out the likeness of their idols”), and the KJV says the heathen “sought to paint the likeness of their images” in it. Who acts changes.
- 3:18, 3:22, 3:53 — Judas speaks of saving ‘Before Heaven’ and says ‘He Himself will crush them’. The Latin and KJV both name God here (“the God of heaven”, “the Lord himself”, “O God”). The Greek’s reverent avoidance of the divine name is a feature of 1 Maccabees that the later translations smooth over.
- 3:41 — The merchants bring silver and gold ‘along with shackles’ to buy captives. The Latin and KJV have “servants” instead. The Greek words pedas (shackles) and paidas (servants) sounded alike; both translations follow paidas.
Disparate: KJV 3:48
Open questions
- Why does 1 Maccabees prefer ‘Heaven’ to the name of God, and does supplying the name change the book’s voice?
- What did the writer of 3:48 mean by the nations consulting idols, and which reading best explains the others?
1 Maccabees 4 · Victory at Emmaus and the rededication of the altar
Judas defeats Gorgias at Emmaus and Lysias at Beth-zur, then cleanses the sanctuary and dedicates a new altar on the twenty-fifth of Chislev, the origin of Hanukkah. The differences concern place names, how confidently the prayers speak of God’s help, and which furnishings were brought into the temple.
- 4:29 — The Greek says Lysias’s army ‘came into Idumea and encamped at Beth-zur’. The Latin has “Judea” and “Beth-horon”, a different region and town, likely carried over from the battle of 3:16. The KJV agrees with the Greek (“Idumea”, “Bethsura”).
- 4:10 — Judas prays ‘perhaps He will favour us’. The Latin removes the ‘perhaps’ and names the Lord: “the Lord will have mercy on us”. The KJV keeps the hesitation (“if peradventure”) but also adds “the Lord”.
- 4:24, 4:55 — After victory they ‘blessed Heaven’, and at the dedication they ‘blessed toward heaven the One who had prospered them’. The Latin names “God” in 4:24, and the KJV names “the Lord” and “the God of heaven”. The praise itself, “for His mercy is for ever”, is shared.
Open questions
- Why might an early copyist have written Beth-horon for Beth-zur in 4:29?
- What does waiting ‘until a prophet should come’ (4:46) suggest about how the community understood its own authority?
Chapters 5–8
1 Maccabees 5 · Campaigns to rescue the Jews of Gilead and Galilee
After the rededication of the temple, neighbouring peoples turn on the Jews living among them, and Judas, Jonathan and Simon lead rescue campaigns in Idumea, Gilead and Galilee, while two commanders left at home suffer defeat at Jamnia. Because 1 Maccabees survives only in Greek, the comparisons here are with the Old Latin (an early Latin translation from the Greek) and with the King James Version, which also translated from Greek; the differences mostly concern place names and verse division.
- 5:35, 5:66 — The Greek text used here reads that Judas ‘passed through Marisa’ and earlier attacked Alema. The Latin and the KJV both read “Samaria” and “Maspha” (Mizpah). The Greek manuscripts themselves have Samaria and Maspha; the modern critical edition corrects them on geographical grounds. Which towns are meant changes the route of the campaign.
- 5:3 — The Greek says the sons of Esau were besieging Israel. The KJV reads “because they besieged Gael”, which seems to come from a damaged form of the name Israel. The Latin treats Akrabattene as a second enemy group and lacks the taking of spoils.
- 5:63 — The Greek honours ‘The man Judas and his brothers’ personally. The Latin reads “the men of Judah”, turning praise of one family into praise of the tribe. The KJV keeps the Greek: “the man Judas and his brethren.” This matters for a chapter that contrasts Judas’ family with the commanders who sought a name for themselves.
Open questions
- Should a translation follow the manuscripts (Samaria, Maspha) or the editors’ geographical corrections (Marisa, Alema)?
- Does the Latin “men of Judah” in 5:63 weaken the book’s point about the chosen family of Judas?
1 Maccabees 6 · Death of Antiochus and the battle of Beth-zechariah
Antiochus IV dies in Persia confessing the evils he did in Jerusalem, and his young son’s regent Lysias marches against Judea with elephants, defeats Judas at Beth-zechariah, and makes a peace he then partly breaks. The main textual differences concern the number of men on each elephant, the role of the cavalry, and several details of the siege.
- 6:37 — The Saints reading places ‘four fighting men and its Indian driver’ on each elephant. The Latin and KJV both have thirty-two men (“two and thirty strong men”), which is what the Greek manuscripts read. Modern editors judge thirty-two impossible for one tower; the manuscript reading greatly enlarges the force.
- 6:38 — The Greek has the cavalry on the wings ‘threatening the enemy and shielding the phalanxes.’ The Latin makes them urge the army forward with trumpets, and the KJV has them “giving them signs what to do, and being harnessed all over amidst the ranks.” The same rare Greek words were understood in three ways.
- 6:43 — The hero who kills the elephant is ‘Eleazar Avaran’ in the Greek, Avaran being the family surname also given in chapter 2. The Latin calls him “son of Saura”, making a surname into a father’s name; the KJV has “surnamed Savaran”, a spelling of the same name.
Disparate: Latin 6:37 · KJV 6:37
Open questions
- Does Antiochus’ confession in 6:12-13 read as repentance or only as recognition of cause and effect?
- Why might the king break his oath at Mount Zion yet still grant the Jews their customs?
1 Maccabees 7 · Alcimus, Nicanor and the Day of Nicanor
Demetrius seizes the Seleucid throne and sends Bacchides and the would-be priest Alcimus to Judea, then Nicanor, who threatens the Temple and dies in battle at Adasa. The main textual differences lie in casualty numbers, place-names, and how the Latin and the King James Version (KJV) read a few ambiguous Greek phrases.
- 7:32 — The Greek says ‘About five hundred of Nicanor’s men fell’. The Latin (an Old Latin translation from the Greek) and the KJV both read “five thousand”. Greek manuscripts differ on this number, so the size of Judas’s first victory over Nicanor depends on which reading is followed.
- 7:19 — The Greek has Bacchides seize ‘many of the men who had deserted to him’. The KJV reads “the men that had forsaken him” and the Latin “those who had fled from him”, which reverses whose side these men had left. The Latin also spells the camp “Beth-zecha”.
- 7:9 — In the Greek the king ‘commanded Bacchides to exact vengeance’. The Latin adds that he was sent “to see the devastation Judas had caused” and its “him” can be read as Alcimus. The KJV says the king made Alcimus “high priest”, where the Greek says ‘confirmed Alcimus in the priesthood’.
Disparate: Latin 7:32 · KJV 7:32
Open questions
- Does the larger casualty figure of five thousand fit the small force Judas had at Caphar-salama?
- Why might the Latin and KJV readers need the Assyrian king named in Judas’s prayer?
1 Maccabees 8 · Judas’s treaty with Rome
Judas hears of Roman power and sends envoys to make an alliance, and the Senate’s treaty is recorded on bronze tablets. The differences are mostly in verse division, with a few points of detail in the treaty terms and the envoys’ ancestry.
- 8:30 — The Greek allows changes to the treaty only if ‘both parties decide to add or remove anything’. The Latin reads “either party”, and the KJV “the one party or the other”. That changes the procedure from joint agreement to a right either side could exercise.
- 8:7 — The Greek lists the terms imposed on Antiochus the Great, ending with ‘make a territorial settlement’. The Latin reads “a fixed payment” and the KJV “that which was agreed upon”, so only the Greek points clearly to the surrender of lands named in the next verse.
- 8:17 — The Greek names the envoy ‘Eupolemus son of John son of Accos’. The Latin gives his grandfather as “Jacob”, while the KJV keeps “Accos”. Accos (Hakkoz) was a priestly family, so the Greek name links the envoy to a known priestly line.
Open questions
- What did an alliance with a distant Gentile power mean for a movement fighting foreign rule?
- Why might later copyists have read the amendment clause as a right of either party?
Chapters 9–12
1 Maccabees 9 · The death of Judas and the rise of Jonathan
Judas falls at Elasa against Bacchides, Jonathan takes his place, avenges his brother John, escapes across the Jordan, and eventually makes peace with Bacchides. Most differences are in verse division and place-names, with a few changes of detail in the Latin (an Old Latin translation from the Greek).
- 9:48 — The Greek ends Jonathan’s escape plainly: ‘The enemy did not cross the Jordan after them.’ The Latin lacks that clause and says the men swam across “toward them”, leaving the direction unclear. The King James Version (KJV) agrees with the Greek that the pursuers did not cross.
- 9:35 — In the Greek, Jonathan asks the Nabateans ‘to allow their many belongings to be deposited with them’, that is, to keep his baggage safe. The Latin asks them to “lend them their equipment”, reversing the direction of the request. The KJV names the brother “John”, a name the Greek gives in 9:36.
- 9:37 — The Greek says the bride came ‘from Nadabath’. The KJV keeps “Nadabatha”, while the Latin reads “Madaba”, the town of the sons of Jambri named in the previous verse. The Latin may have replaced a rare name with a familiar one.
Open questions
- Why might the account record that Judas’s other deeds ‘were not written down’?
- Does the Latin “lend them their equipment” make sense of the attack on John in 9:36?
1 Maccabees 10 · Rival kings court Jonathan
Alexander Balas and Demetrius I compete for Jonathan’s support with letters, titles and tax exemptions; Jonathan sides with Alexander, becomes high priest, and defeats Apollonius at Azotus. The Old Latin (the early Latin version printed in the Vulgate) and the KJV mostly agree with the Greek, with differences in court titles, building details and verse division.
- 10:11 — The Greek has walls built with ‘four-foot stones for fortification’. Both the Latin and the KJV have “squared stones” (“square stones”). Greek manuscripts differ by a few letters here, and both translations follow the reading “squared”, so the difference reflects the Greek copies they used.
- 10:29–30 — Demetrius releases the Jews from taxes and from ‘the third of the grain crop and the half of the fruit of the trees’. The Latin moves the grain exemption into verse 29, leaving only the fruit in verse 30. The content is the same, but the verse boundaries differ, which affects how the verses are cited.
- 10:31 — In the Greek, Jerusalem is to be ‘holy and exempt, free of tithes and dues’. The Latin instead says its tithes and tribute “belong to it”, turning a tax exemption into a grant of revenue to the city. The KJV keeps the Greek sense, “free … from tenths and tributes”.
Open questions
- Why would Demetrius’s generous offer fail where Alexander’s smaller one succeeded, according to 10:46–47?
- Does the reading “squared” or ‘four-foot stones’ better fit a fortification wall?
1 Maccabees 11 · Ptolemy’s betrayal and Demetrius II
Ptolemy VI turns against Alexander, takes the crown of Asia, and both kings die; Demetrius II makes terms with Jonathan, then breaks them, while Tryphon raises the young Antiochus VI. The Latin and KJV mostly agree with the Greek, but differ on names, places, titles, and on a few verbs that change who does what.
- 11:2 — Ptolemy ‘went out to Syria’ and Alexander was ‘his father-in-law’. The KJV reads “into Spain” and “his brother in law”, both at odds with the Greek and the Latin. These appear to be errors in the early English text rather than readings of any Greek manuscript.
- 11:13 — The Greek says Ptolemy ‘put on the diadem of Asia’ and then placed two diadems on his head. The Latin and KJV give only the two diadems (or crowns), lacking the first clause. The Greek doubling stresses that Ptolemy claimed the Seleucid crown for himself.
- 11:47–48 — In the Greek the Jews kill ‘about a hundred thousand’ in Antioch in verse 47. The Latin places the killing in verse 48. The KJV follows the Greek division. The figure itself is the same in all three.
Open questions
- Why does the author record Jonathan’s prayer at 11:71 just before the reversal of the battle?
- How did the honorific ‘father’ for a royal minister work in the Seleucid court?
1 Maccabees 12 · Rome, Sparta and Tryphon’s trap
Jonathan renews the alliance with Rome and writes to Sparta, recalling an earlier letter claiming kinship through Abraham; Tryphon then lures him into Ptolemais and seizes him. The differences lie mainly in the Spartan king’s name in the KJV, in who threatens whom at Beth-shan in the Latin, and in what happened to Jonathan’s two thousand men.
- 12:7, 12:19 — The Spartan king who wrote to Onias is ‘Areus’. The KJV names him “Darius” in 12:7 and makes “Oniares” the sender in 12:19. Both follow corrupted Greek copies; the Latin keeps Areus and Onias, as the Greek does.
- 12:21 — The Spartan letter states that Spartans and Jews ‘are brothers and are of the lineage of Abraham’. Latin and KJV agree. The claim of shared descent is the basis of the whole exchange of letters.
- 12:42 — Tryphon ‘feared to stretch out his hands against him’. The Latin reverses the roles: Jonathan came with a great army “to lay hands upon” Tryphon. The KJV follows the Greek. The Latin makes Jonathan the aggressor at Beth-shan.
Open questions
- What did the claim of kinship with Sparta offer the Jews in their political situation?
- Why does Jonathan trust Tryphon at 12:46 after the treachery he had already seen?
Chapters 13–16
1 Maccabees 13 · Simon takes command and Jonathan is killed
Simon succeeds his brother Jonathan, Tryphon kills Jonathan despite a ransom, and Simon builds the family tomb at Modein, wins freedom from tribute, and takes Gazara and the Jerusalem citadel. The main differences lie in the Old Latin (the early Latin translation made from the Greek), which compresses or reinterprets several verses.
- 13:22 — The Greek says Tryphon ‘did not go because of the snow. He set out and came to Gilead.’ The Latin reads “did not come into Gilead,” attaching the negative to the destination and reversing where he went. The KJV agrees with the Greek.
- 13:23 — In the Greek, Tryphon ‘killed Jonathan, and Jonathan was buried there.’ The Latin has “he killed Jonathan and his sons there,” adding sons who appear nowhere else in the Greek account. The KJV keeps the burial.
- 13:43 — The Saints reading has Simon encamp ‘against Gazara’, where his son John later lived. Most Greek manuscripts, the Latin and the KJV read “Gaza,” a different city on the coast. Modern editions adopt Gazara because the story continues there.
Open questions
- Why might the Old Latin translator have read Gilead as a place Tryphon never reached?
- Does reading Gaza or Gazara change how Simon’s conquests should be understood?
1 Maccabees 14 · Praise of Simon and the bronze decree
A poem praises Simon’s peaceful rule, Sparta and Rome renew their alliance, and the people honour Simon with a decree on bronze tablets naming him leader and high priest. The main differences concern who speaks in 14:25, how the decree is divided into verses, and readings of single words in 14:23 and 14:35.
- 14:24–26 — In the Greek, ‘the people’ who ask ‘What thanks shall we return to Simon and his sons?’ are the Jews, who then make the decree. The Latin adds “When the Roman people heard,” so the Romans give thanks. The KJV keeps the Greek.
- 14:23 — The Saints reading closes the Spartan letter and adds that ‘They wrote a copy of these things to Simon’. The Latin and the KJV both read “we have written,” keeping the sentence inside the Spartan letter, which may reflect a first-person reading in some Greek copies.
- 14:35 — The Greek says ‘The people saw Simon’s faithfulness’. The Latin has Simon’s “deeds,” and the KJV “sang the acts of Simon,” both apparently following Greek copies that read a different word for faithfulness.
Open questions
- What does the condition ‘until a faithful prophet should arise’ suggest about how the people understood Simon’s office?
- Why might the Latin have made the Romans, not the Jews, give thanks for Simon?
1 Maccabees 15 · Antiochus VII, Rome’s letter, and the breach with Simon
Antiochus son of Demetrius grants Simon privileges, besieges Tryphon at Dora, then breaks with Simon and sends Cendebaeus against Judea, while a Roman letter protects the Jews. The differences are mostly verse division, place names, and a few words in the Latin and the KJV.
- 15:39–41 — The king orders Cendebaeus to ‘rebuild Kedron’. The Latin reads “build Gedor,” a different place name, and moves the building notice into 15:40. The KJV keeps Cedron, though its 15:41 misprints it “Cedrou”.
- 15:35–36 — In the Greek the words ‘He did not answer him a word’ open 15:36. Both the Latin and the KJV end 15:35 with them. The content is shared; only the verse division differs.
- 15:23 — The Roman letter goes to a long list of places. The Latin reads “Lampsacus” for ‘Sampsame’ and reorders the islands; the KJV names Aradus twice and lacks Phaselis.
Open questions
- Why did Antiochus refuse Simon’s help once Tryphon was trapped at Dora?
- What did the right to strike coinage (15:6) signify for Judea’s independence?
1 Maccabees 16 · John’s victory and the murder of Simon
John and Judas defeat Cendebaeus, but Ptolemy son of Abubus murders Simon and two sons at a banquet near Jericho, and John escapes to succeed his father. The differences lie mainly in the Latin’s shorter wording in 16:3 and small additions in the Latin and the KJV.
- 16:3 — Simon tells his sons ‘through mercy ye are mature in years. Take my place and my brother’s’. The Latin lacks the words about mercy and age and reads “Stand in my place, my brothers.” The KJV keeps the Greek and supplies “God’s mercy.”
- 16:8 — The Saints reading says ‘They sounded the trumpets’. The Latin and the KJV both read “holy trumpets,” probably following Greek copies that add the word, which echoes the priestly trumpets of the Law.
- 16:16 — Ptolemy’s men ‘entered the banquet room against Simon, and killed him’. The Latin lacks ‘against Simon,’ and the KJV softens ‘had become drunk’ to “had drunk largely.” The treachery is the same in all.
Open questions
- Why does the book end with John rather than Simon’s death?
- What might the lost ‘book of the days’ of John’s high priesthood have contained?
Disparate verses
Verses where at least one comparison records a major difference of meaning or consequence. The Disparate study examines the Hebrew–Greek cases in depth.
- 2:9 (Latin) — KJV “her infants are slain in the streets”: agrees with the Greek.
- 3:48 (KJV) — KJV “wherein the heathen had sought to paint the likeness of their images” makes the gentiles deface the law book.
- 6:37 (Latin, KJV) — KJV ‘two and thirty strong men’ on each beast, against the critical Greek ‘four’.
- 7:32 (Latin, KJV) — KJV ‘about five thousand men’ fell and ‘the rest fled’;
Points to be checked
Small inconsistencies noticed during the research. None has been changed in the reading text.
- 2:63 — The Latin existing note quotes Greek–English “planning will perish”, but the Saints reading has ‘his thought shall perish’. Note text outdated.
- 3:40 — The Saints reading has “He set out with all their force”; the Greek verb is usually printed as plural (“they set out”), as in the Latin and KJV; check.
- 5:32 — The Saints reading has “our brothers”; the Latin and KJV read “your brothers”; check the Rahlfs reading.
- 10:87 — KJV text in the packet reads “having any spoils”; the 1611 sense requires “many”. Probably a transcription error in the KJV source file.
- 12:24 — KJV text in the packet reads “Demebius”; should be “Demetrius”. Transcription error in the KJV source file.
- 12:53 — KJV text in the packet reads “round about then”; should be “them”. Transcription error in the KJV source file.
- 16:24 — The Saints reading appears to leave out the Greek word for “behold”, which Rahlfs prints here and which both the Latin and the KJV render; confirm whether the omission is intended.
- The Vulgate comparison page still shows “assessment open” on 0 verses, and the KJV comparison page shows “review pending” on 921. The new categories can be carried onto those pages after review.
Questions still open
The research flags these as questions for specialist review, one from each chapter.
- 1 Maccabees 1 — Why might the Old Latin translator have regrouped the temple inventory and the decree into different verses?
- 1 Maccabees 2 — How does the Latin “stood firm” in 2:16 change the picture of Mattathias at the start of the revolt?
- 1 Maccabees 3 — Why does 1 Maccabees prefer ‘Heaven’ to the name of God, and does supplying the name change the book’s voice?
- 1 Maccabees 4 — Why might an early copyist have written Beth-horon for Beth-zur in 4:29?
- 1 Maccabees 5 — Should a translation follow the manuscripts (Samaria, Maspha) or the editors’ geographical corrections (Marisa, Alema)?
- 1 Maccabees 6 — Does Antiochus’ confession in 6:12-13 read as repentance or only as recognition of cause and effect?
- 1 Maccabees 7 — Does the larger casualty figure of five thousand fit the small force Judas had at Caphar-salama?
- 1 Maccabees 8 — What did an alliance with a distant Gentile power mean for a movement fighting foreign rule?
- 1 Maccabees 9 — Why might the account record that Judas’s other deeds ‘were not written down’?
- 1 Maccabees 10 — Why would Demetrius’s generous offer fail where Alexander’s smaller one succeeded, according to 10:46–47?
- 1 Maccabees 11 — Why does the author record Jonathan’s prayer at 11:71 just before the reversal of the battle?
- 1 Maccabees 12 — What did the claim of kinship with Sparta offer the Jews in their political situation?
- 1 Maccabees 13 — Why might the Old Latin translator have read Gilead as a place Tryphon never reached?
- 1 Maccabees 14 — What does the condition ‘until a faithful prophet should arise’ suggest about how the people understood Simon’s office?
- 1 Maccabees 15 — Why did Antiochus refuse Simon’s help once Tryphon was trapped at Dora?
- 1 Maccabees 16 — Why does the book end with John rather than Simon’s death?
About this edition
Research compiled 6 October 2026 from the published reading text (checked verse by verse against the chapter pages), the Hebrew–Greek, Vulgate and KJV comparison editions, and the Disparate study. The Latin–Greek and KJV–Greek classifications are new, AI-prepared and provisional; a second, independent AI review checked every chapter note and a sample of the classifications, and its corrections are applied. This is a working study edition; independent specialist review is still pending.
Study notes by Saints.Bible · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Suggest a correction
About this reading and its sources
Bespoke Saints English
- Content available
- This chapter response, not a corpus-wide coverage count.
- Displayed scope
- 32 identified reading units in this response.
- Review
- Independent review is not certified by this disclosure. The source-count snapshot declares: Provisional editorial edition. README: "Full critical-apparatus, Göttingen and UBS6/ECM comparisons, independent Greek review, and human read-aloud review remain pending." Genesis 1–11 is the accepted benchmark.
- Publication
- Served on Saints.Bible. This does not establish acceptance of a manuscript.
Fingerprint covers identified Saints-column readings only. Retained Hebrew, Latin and King James comparison columns and Workspace quotations have separate sources; their edition revisions and review status are not certified here.
The identified chapter readings match the installed Bespoke book data after whitespace normalization.
Edition facts and counting rules · Sources and review register
Snapshot details
Family: saints-bespoke-english
Fingerprint: sha256:3fd864afe00f205fa7febf2d95f54209f7f6d0ec501e5a1f2c53664f3e503f8f
A fingerprint identifies content; it is not a quality score or scholarly approval.
{"schema_version":1,"environment":"production","publication":{"status":"served_on_production","scope":"This rendered response only; no editorial acceptance is inferred."},"review":{"status":"not_independently_certified_by_this_module","source_declaration":"Provisional editorial edition. README: \"Full critical-apparatus, Göttingen and UBS6/ECM comparisons, independent Greek review, and human read-aloud review remain pending.\" Genesis 1–11 is the accepted benchmark."},"parity":{"reader_search_downloads":"not_established","november_12_manuscripts":"not_assumed_published"},"facts_path":"/study-guides/edition-facts/","edition_family_id":"saints-bespoke-english","label":"Bespoke Saints English","surface":"parallel","book":"1-maccabees","chapter":8,"availability":{"status":"identified_reading_units_displayed","count":32,"unit":"identified displayed reading units","scope":"This chapter response, not a corpus-wide coverage count."},"snapshot":{"id":"sha256:3fd864afe00f205fa7febf2d95f54209f7f6d0ec501e5a1f2c53664f3e503f8f","algorithm":"sha256","basis":"saints-displayed-units-v1","normalization":"Ordered chapter keys and visible text; whitespace collapsed. Plain-reader reference labels and identified editorial-note links excluded. Markup and comparison columns excluded."},"runtime_bespoke_match":"exact_identified_chapter_units","scope_note":"Fingerprint covers identified Saints-column readings only. Retained Hebrew, Latin and King James comparison columns and Workspace quotations have separate sources; their edition revisions and review status are not certified here.","runtime_artifact":{"path":"saints-bespoke-reader/data/1-maccabees.json","sha256":"fed3f65fb723282c7390641981a58da3946f138e610411a3c74dc300f81b2e4b","scope":"Installed book JSON bytes. Matching this file does not establish independent review or all-surface publication parity."}}