
Joshua 5 — Hebrew and Greek compared
Disparate in this chapter: MT 5:4, MT 5:5, MT 5:6
Each card keeps the independently rendered source readings above their shared comparison and reception notes. The badge records the source’s governing classification; disparate readings are marked in red. Each reading retains its original reference.
Joshua 5
The covenant renewed: circumcision of the heart in Christ
Patristic reading: Justin interprets the stone knives through Christ’s words and circumcision of the heart [JUS, §113]. Colossians 2:11–12 supplies an apostolic circumcision-and-baptism connection; the translations retain the physical rite.
5:1–8 | Fear beyond the Jordan; circumcision at Gilgal
Chapter reception study · Joshua 5
Circumcision and entry
2. Rabbinic teaching. Rashi explains the renewed communal circumcision and the covenantal requirement for entry; he also transmits a second interpretation concerning the rite’s completion. [R]
3. Saints’ teaching. Justin reads Joshua’s name, circumcision, and temporary allotment through Christ and the promised enduring inheritance. His typology is a later interpretive argument. [S]
4. Reception relationship: Different. Rashi explains the communal rite and inheritance; Justin develops spiritual circumcision through Christ. Neither interpretation resolves forty versus forty-two years or the generation described in 5:4–6.
5. Why these interpretations differ. Ritual explanation and Christological typology develop from different interpretive commitments; the numerical and narrative variants require separate textual evidence.
This study concerns the passages and themes just named. Verse-level excerpts and lexical checks below keep their narrower scope.
Verse MT 5:1 Different
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:1
When all the kings of the Amorites west of the Jordan and all the kings of the Canaanites by the sea heard that YHWH had dried up the Jordan’s waters before the sons of Israel until we had crossed, their hearts melted, and no spirit remained in them because of the sons of Israel.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:1
When the kings of the Amorites beyond the Jordan and the kings of Phoenicia by the sea heard that the Lord God had dried up the River Jordan before the sons of Israel as they crossed, their minds melted; they were dismayed, and no understanding remained in them because of the sons of Israel.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| When all the kings of the Amorites west of the Jordan and all the kings of the Canaanites by the sea heard that YHWH had dried up the Jordan’s waters before the sons of Israel until we had crossed, their hearts melted, and no spirit remained in them because of the sons of Israel. | When the kings of the Amorites beyond the Jordan and the kings of Phoenicia by the sea heard that the Lord God had dried up the River Jordan before the sons of Israel as they crossed, their minds melted; they were dismayed, and no understanding remained in them because of the sons of Israel. |
Classification & Notes
Different
Text: Hebrew’s displayed written form is first-person “we crossed”; Greek has “they.” Canaanites / Phoenicia and spirit / understanding are preserved as source-specific expressions.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:1 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:1
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:1
Who were on the western side of the Jordan. On the side to which Bnei Yisroel crossed, which is the western side, since they had been on the eastern side.
Rashi on Joshua 5:1:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Different. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
Verse MT 5:2 Different
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:2
At that time YHWH said to Joshua, “Make flint knives for yourself, and again circumcise the sons of Israel a second time.”
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:2
At that time the Lord said to Joshua, “Make stone knives for yourself from sharp rock, and sit down and circumcise the sons of Israel.”
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| At that time YHWH said to Joshua, “Make flint knives for yourself, and again circumcise the sons of Israel a second time.” | At that time the Lord said to Joshua, “Make stone knives for yourself from sharp rock, and sit down and circumcise the sons of Israel.” |
Classification & Notes
Different
Text: Greek has “sit down” instead of “again … a second time.” Neither wording licenses inserting later spiritual interpretation into the command.
Rabbinic: Rashi gives sharp knives through the Aramaic rendering and explains a renewed communal circumcision after the one in Egypt [R5, 5:2].
Saints: Justin interprets the stone knives as Christ’s words effecting circumcision of the heart [JUS, §113]. The physical rite remains explicit in both translations.
Context and interpretation: The differing commands should be read beside the shared physical act in verse 3. The stone-knife typology belongs after the textual comparison.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:2 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:2
Original-language check. Hebrew חַרְבוֹת צֻרִים has been understood through the relation of sharp edges and flint; Greek μαχαίρας πετρίνας expressly says stone knives. Rashi’s comment emphasizes sharp knives. BHS, Joshua 5 · Rahlfs–Hanhart, Joshua 5.
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:2
Sharp knives. As translated by Targum, sharp knives. Similarly, ‘You also turned back the sharp edge of his sword.’ When the sharp edge is turned sideways it does not cut well. ‘Similarly, ‘Every weapon that is sharpened against you?’
Rashi on Joshua 5:2:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Different. Reception: Different. Rashi’s lexical and ritual explanations differ in scope from Justin’s inward-circumcision typology. Justin’s reference to a second circumcision should not be silently imported into the shorter selected Greek command.
5. How and why. The material/edge relation is a lexical question. Justin’s use of the stone knives is later typology, not proof of why the translator chose the Greek adjective.
Verse MT 5:3 Same
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:3
Joshua made flint knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at the Hill of the Foreskins.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:3
Joshua made sharp stone knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at the place called Hill of the Foreskins.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| Joshua made flint knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at the Hill of the Foreskins. | Joshua made sharp stone knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at the place called Hill of the Foreskins. |
Classification & Notes
Same
Text: The operation and descriptive place-name correspond.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:3 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:3
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:3
Gival Ha-orlos. [Lit. Hill of the foreskins] It was so called, because of the event, [i.e., the mass of foreskins that were circumcised] which were made into a hill.
Rashi on Joshua 5:3:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Same. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies correspondence in meaning. English word choice can differ within that agreement; no historical textual alteration is established by this classification. Reception purposes are explained in the chapter study.
Verse MT 5:4 Disparate
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:4
This is why Joshua circumcised them: all the males who came out of Egypt, all the men of war, had died in the wilderness on the journey after leaving Egypt.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:4
This is how Joshua purified the sons of Israel: those born along the way and those among the people who had left Egypt who were still uncircumcised—
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| This is why Joshua circumcised them: all the males who came out of Egypt, all the men of war, had died in the wilderness on the journey after leaving Egypt. | This is how Joshua purified the sons of Israel: those born along the way and those among the people who had left Egypt who were still uncircumcised— |
Classification & Notes Disparate
Text: Hebrew explains the death of the departing military generation; Greek identifies uncircumcised people from the journey and the exodus. Read with verses 5–6 for the contrasting account.
Wording and significance: Read Greek verses 4–5 as one sentence: the people circumcised include those born on the journey and uncircumcised persons who had left Egypt. Hebrew begins by explaining the death of the departing warriors.
Jewish interpretation / biblical context: The Hebrew explanation unfolds across 5:4–7; it separates the circumcised exodus generation from their uncircumcised successors. Verse divisions should not sever the Greek sentence.
Christian reception: Justin, Dialogue with Trypho 113 interprets the stone knives through Christ’s words and inward circumcision. His typology concerns the rite; it does not settle the competing accounts of who was uncircumcised.
Reading the evidence together: Both narrate a communal circumcision under Joshua. Their explanations of its necessity differ, and spiritual interpretation should leave that distinction visible.
Origin and limits: This is a difference in narrative formulation, not merely a missing English word. Its historical direction is unresolved without further textual evidence.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:4 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:4
Collected study: Joshua 5:4 in the Disparate guide
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:4
And this is the reason. [Lit. and this is the thing] After this speech he circumcised them. He said to them. “Do you think you will inherit this land while you are yet uncircumcised? Was it not said to Avrohom, ‘And you will preserve My covenant etc.’ ‘and I will give you and your descendants after you, the land of your sojournings.’”
Rashi on Joshua 5:4:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Disparate. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
Verse MT 5:5 Disparate
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:5
All the people who came out had been circumcised, but none of the people born in the wilderness on the journey after leaving Egypt had been circumcised.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:5
Joshua circumcised all these.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| All the people who came out had been circumcised, but none of the people born in the wilderness on the journey after leaving Egypt had been circumcised. | Joshua circumcised all these. |
Classification & Notes Disparate
Text: Hebrew expressly says all who left Egypt were circumcised; Greek’s sentence, begun in verse 4, includes uncircumcised people who left Egypt. This is a substantive narrative contrast, not merely shorter wording.
Wording and significance: Hebrew explicitly describes the departing people as circumcised. Greek completes the preceding sentence with Joshua circumcising those just identified as uncircumcised. Reading this verse alone obscures the contrast.
Jewish interpretation / biblical context: Joshua 5:7 supplies the shared successor-generation setting. The broader agreement does not cancel the different statements about the exodus generation.
Christian reception: Colossians 2:11-12 relates circumcision to life in Christ and baptism. This is an editorial theological comparison, not a quotation of Joshua 5:5.
Reading the evidence together: The physical rite and the later Christian application answer different questions. Neither permits rewriting the ancient account to eliminate its historical difficulty.
Origin and limits: The longer sentence in Greek explains the alignment across verses 4–5. It does not by itself explain why the two accounts describe the earlier generation differently.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:5 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:5
Collected study: Joshua 5:5 in the Disparate guide
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:5
Were not circumcised. As I have previously explained, the north wind had not blown. It was these who were now to be circumcised.
Rashi on Joshua 5:5:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Disparate. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
Verse MT 5:6 Disparate
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:6
For the sons of Israel walked in the wilderness forty years, until the whole nation of warriors who came out of Egypt had perished, because they did not obey YHWH’s voice. YHWH swore that He would not let them see the land He had sworn to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:6
For Israel had lived forty-two years in the wilderness of Madbaritis. Therefore most of the fighting men who had left the land of Egypt were uncircumcised, those who disobeyed God’s commands. He decreed that they should not see the land the Lord swore to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| For the sons of Israel walked in the wilderness forty years, until the whole nation of warriors who came out of Egypt had perished, because they did not obey YHWH’s voice. YHWH swore that He would not let them see the land He had sworn to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey. | For Israel had lived forty-two years in the wilderness of Madbaritis. Therefore most of the fighting men who had left the land of Egypt were uncircumcised, those who disobeyed God’s commands. He decreed that they should not see the land the Lord swore to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey. |
Classification & Notes Disparate
Text: Forty / forty-two years differs. Greek’s explanation of uncircumcision and Hebrew’s account of the generation’s death also give this verse a different narrative force.
Wording and significance: Greek states forty-two years; Hebrew states forty. The difference accompanies distinct explanations of the generation’s disobedience and uncircumcision.
Jewish interpretation / biblical context: Numbers 14:33-34 supplies the forty-year wilderness framework. This is biblical context for the Hebrew number, not proof that every witness to Joshua must have that reading.
Christian reception: Hebrews 3:16-19 uses wilderness disobedience to warn against unbelief. Its exhortation does not resolve Joshua’s numerical variant.
Reading the evidence together: The shared warning about disobedience can be studied alongside the differing numbers. A harmonized chronology would conceal the very evidence the comparison is intended to display.
Origin and limits: No particular calculation, copying error, or translator motive has been established for forty-two. Both numbers are retained pending specialist review.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:6 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:6
Collected study: Joshua 5:6 in the Disparate guide
Original-language check. Hebrew אַרְבָּעִים, forty, contrasts with Greek τεσσαράκοντα … καὶ δύο, forty-two. The latter appears within a differently phrased account of the uncircumcised generation. BHS, Joshua 5 · Rahlfs–Hanhart, Joshua 5.
2. Rabbinic teaching. See the attributed Joshua 5 study for relevant chapter context. No direct Rashi comment on this aligned unit is supplied by the consulted selection.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Disparate. The number differs even where reception agrees on covenant and disobedience. No rabbinic or patristic theological synthesis makes forty and forty-two the same number.
5. How and why. The variant is confirmed in the selected running texts. No particular counting scheme or copying error has been demonstrated for this unit.
Verse MT 5:7 Same
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:7
He raised up their sons in their place. Joshua circumcised them, because they were uncircumcised; they had not been circumcised on the journey.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:7
In their place He appointed their sons, whom Joshua circumcised because they had remained uncircumcised along the way.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| He raised up their sons in their place. Joshua circumcised them, because they were uncircumcised; they had not been circumcised on the journey. | In their place He appointed their sons, whom Joshua circumcised because they had remained uncircumcised along the way. |
Classification & Notes
Same
Text: Both describe the succeeding generation and Joshua’s circumcision of it.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:7 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:7
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:7
And their children whom He brought up in place of them. And their children whom He brought up in place of them, they were born in the wilderness it was them whom Yehoshua circumcised.
Rashi on Joshua 5:7:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Same. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies correspondence in meaning. English word choice can differ within that agreement; no historical textual alteration is established by this classification. Reception purposes are explained in the chapter study.
Verse MT 5:8 Same
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:8
When the whole nation had finished being circumcised, they remained in their places in the camp until they recovered.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:8
After being circumcised, they rested there in the camp until they recovered.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| When the whole nation had finished being circumcised, they remained in their places in the camp until they recovered. | After being circumcised, they rested there in the camp until they recovered. |
Classification & Notes
Same
Text: Rest and recovery in the camp correspond.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:8 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:8
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:8
They remained in their places. They remained in their places and they did not besiege the city.
Rashi on Joshua 5:8:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Same. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies correspondence in meaning. English word choice can differ within that agreement; no historical textual alteration is established by this classification. Reception purposes are explained in the chapter study.
Passover and holy ground: the Paschal gift of Christ
Published liturgical anchors: 5:10–15 at Great and Holy Saturday Vespers [L2]; 5:13–15 for the Synaxis of the Bodiless Powers [L3]; 5:9a, 10–12 on the Roman Fourth Sunday of Lent, Year C [L4]. The last is paired with 2 Corinthians 5:17–21 and Luke 15:1–3, 11–32.
5:9 | The reproach rolled away
L4 selects the opening part of verse 9 (9a); the full verse is translated here.
Verse MT 5:9 Similar
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:9
YHWH said to Joshua, “Today I have rolled away the reproach of Egypt from you.” So that place was called Gilgal, as it is to this day.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:9
The Lord said to Joshua son of Nun, “Today I have removed the reproach of Egypt from you.” He called that place Gilgal.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| YHWH said to Joshua, “Today I have rolled away the reproach of Egypt from you.” So that place was called Gilgal, as it is to this day. | The Lord said to Joshua son of Nun, “Today I have removed the reproach of Egypt from you.” He called that place Gilgal. |
Classification & Notes
Similar
Text: Hebrew’s “rolled away” echoes Gilgal and adds “to this day”; Greek uses the more general “removed.”
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:9 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:9
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:9
I have removed. (Lit. I have rolled) I have removed the ridicule of the Egyptians who had said [when they were leaving], “See that ‘ Raah ’ is before you. There is a star named Raah, which is a symbol of blood. We see it overpowering you in the wilderness.” This is what Moshe referred to in the wilderness [when he said,] “Why should the Egptians speak, saying, ‘With Raah, He took them out.’” But they did not know that [the blood they saw] was the blood of circumcision. And now when they were circumcised in the days of Yehoshua, and the blood of circumcision appeared, that ridicule was removed; for the mixed multitude that went up with them [from Egypt] were still taunting them. This is the way R’ Moshe, Ha Darshan explained [this passage.]
Rashi on Joshua 5:9:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Similar. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note and phrase table identify the modest difference in these renderings. Idiom, word choice, and syntax may explain such effects, but the English spans alone do not prove an ancient translator’s motive or a variant exemplar. See the chapter study for reception purposes.
5:10–12 | The Passover kept in the land
L2 • Holy Saturday, Vespers, fifth reading: first part. L4 • Fourth Sunday of Lent, Year C: 10–12.
Verse MT 5:10 Different
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:10
The sons of Israel camped at Gilgal and kept the Passover on the fourteenth day of the month, at evening, on the plains of Jericho.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:10
The sons of Israel kept the Passover on the fourteenth day of the month, from evening, west of Jericho, beyond the Jordan, in the plain.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| The sons of Israel camped at Gilgal and kept the Passover on the fourteenth day of the month, at evening, on the plains of Jericho. | The sons of Israel kept the Passover on the fourteenth day of the month, from evening, west of Jericho, beyond the Jordan, in the plain. |
Classification & Notes
Different
Text: The date agrees; Hebrew names Gilgal, while Greek supplies the western orientation and Jordan location.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:10 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:10
2. Rabbinic teaching. See the attributed Joshua 5 study for relevant chapter context. No direct Rashi comment on this aligned unit is supplied by the consulted selection.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Different. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
Verse MT 5:11 Different
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:11
On the day after the Passover, on that very day, they ate from the produce of the land: unleavened bread and roasted grain.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:11
They ate from the grain of the land: unleavened bread and new grain. On this day
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| On the day after the Passover, on that very day, they ate from the produce of the land: unleavened bread and roasted grain. | They ate from the grain of the land: unleavened bread and new grain. On this day |
Classification & Notes
Different
Text: Greek has new grain instead of roasted grain and lacks “the day after the Passover.” Its final time phrase continues into verse 12.
Rabbinic: Rashi associates eating the land’s produce with the waving of the omer on the day after Passover [R5, 5:11]. The ritual explanation is not inserted into the verse.
Context and interpretation: The timing clause crosses a Greek verse boundary. The contrast must be assessed with verse 12, not by assuming that the two numbering systems divide the sentence identically.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:11 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:11
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:11
From the day after the Pesach. This was the day of waving the Omer, for they sacrificed the Omer first. From the seventh day of Adar, the day when Moshe died, when the manna stopped falling, they were sufficiently supplied with the manna which was in their vessels which they gathered on the seventh of Adar, as it is said, ‘They ate the manna for forty years.’ But these forty years lacked thirty days— for the manna began to fall on the fifteenth day of Iyar. We must say therefore that in the [matzo] cakes the Bnei Yisroel took with them from Egypt, they tasted the taste of manna.
Rashi on Joshua 5:11:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Different. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
Verse MT 5:12 Different
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:12
The manna ceased the next day, when they ate from the produce of the land. There was no more manna for the sons of Israel; that year they ate from the yield of the land of Canaan.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:12
the manna failed after they had eaten from the grain of the land. There was no longer manna for the sons of Israel; that year they harvested the country of the Phoenicians.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| The manna ceased the next day, when they ate from the produce of the land. There was no more manna for the sons of Israel; that year they ate from the yield of the land of Canaan. | the manna failed after they had eaten from the grain of the land. There was no longer manna for the sons of Israel; that year they harvested the country of the Phoenicians. |
Classification & Notes
Different
Text: Greek says they harvested the country and places the cessation “on this day” across the verse boundary; Hebrew has “the next day.”
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:12 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:12
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:12
No longer did the Bnei Yisroel have manna . Therefore they ate of the grain of the land. If they would have had manna they would not have eaten of the grain, for the manna was agreeable to them. There is a parable for this: One says to a child, “Why are you eating barley bread?” “Because I have no wheat bread.” That is why it is said, ‘no longer did etc.’
Rashi on Joshua 5:12:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Different. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local explanation identifies the changed detail or consequence. Where it gives no evidence for a historical origin, that origin remains unresolved. A translation decision, another source form, and later transmission are distinct explanations; the later interpretations are not proof of any one of them.
5:13–15 | Before the Lord’s commander
L2 • Holy Saturday: concluding part. L3 • Synaxis of the Archangel Michael and the Other Bodiless Powers, Vespers, first reading.
Verse MT 5:13 Same
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:13
When Joshua was by Jericho, he lifted his eyes and saw a man standing opposite him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua approached him and said, “Are you for us or for our adversaries?”
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:13
When Joshua was at Jericho, he looked up and saw a man standing opposite him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua approached and said, “Are you one of ours or one of our opponents?”
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| When Joshua was by Jericho, he lifted his eyes and saw a man standing opposite him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua approached him and said, “Are you for us or for our adversaries?” | When Joshua was at Jericho, he looked up and saw a man standing opposite him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua approached and said, “Are you one of ours or one of our opponents?” |
Classification & Notes
Same
Text: The encounter and question correspond. The figure is first described as a man in both texts.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:13 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:13
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:13
When Yehoshua was in Yericho. From here we can learn that the outskirts of a city are considered part of the city itself, for it impossible to say that Yoshua was actually inside Yericho.
Rashi on Joshua 5:13:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Same. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies correspondence in meaning. English word choice can differ within that agreement; no historical textual alteration is established by this classification. Reception purposes are explained in the chapter study.
Verse MT 5:14 Divergent
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:14
He said, “No; I am the commander of YHWH’s army. Now I have come.” Joshua fell on his face to the earth and bowed down. He said to him, “What does my lord say to his servant?”
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:14
He said to him, “I have now arrived as commander-in-chief of the Lord’s host.” Joshua fell on his face to the earth and said to him, “Master, what do you command your servant?”
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| He said, “No; I am the commander of YHWH’s army. Now I have come.” Joshua fell on his face to the earth and bowed down. He said to him, “What does my lord say to his servant?” | He said to him, “I have now arrived as commander-in-chief of the Lord’s host.” Joshua fell on his face to the earth and said to him, “Master, what do you command your servant?” |
Classification & Notes
Divergent
Text: Greek lacks the initial “No” and separate bowing verb. Capitalization does not resolve the figure’s identity; later interpretations are attributed separately.
Context and interpretation: The absent initial denial makes the response less explicitly oppositional in Greek. Neither source names the figure Michael within this clause.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:14 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:14
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:14
I have now come. —“to help you, for it is impossible for man to battle against it [Yericho] and capture it, to knock down the wall. However in the days of your master, Moshe, I came, but he did not want my presence, as it is said, ‘If your Presence [Adonoy] does not go, etc.’”
Rashi on Joshua 5:14:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Divergent. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies the addition, absence, or rearrangement and its alignment. This establishes the displayed relationship, not the direction of development. Distinguishing expansion, abbreviation, and differing source forms requires witness evidence beyond an English gap.
Verse MT 5:15 Divergent
Hebrew–English: Literal-Smooth(Rabbinic Priority)
MT 5:15
The commander of YHWH’s army said to Joshua, “Remove your sandal from your foot, for the place where you stand is holy.” Joshua did so.
Greek–English: Literal-Smooth(Saints Priority)
LXX 5:15
The Lord’s commander-in-chief said to Joshua, “Loosen the sandal from your feet, for the place where you stand is holy.”
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted words differ in these English renderings; punctuation and capitalization alone are disregarded. English highlighting is not a Hebrew–Greek interlinear. An unmatched English word does not by itself establish an omission in an ancient text.
| Masoretic Hebrew · English | Septuagint Greek · English |
|---|---|
| The commander of YHWH’s army said to Joshua, “Remove your sandal from your foot, for the place where you stand is holy.” Joshua did so. | The Lord’s commander-in-chief said to Joshua, “Loosen the sandal from your feet, for the place where you stand is holy.” |
Classification & Notes
Divergent
Text: Greek lacks the final statement of Joshua’s compliance. Both echo the holy-ground command in Exodus 3:5.
Rabbinic: Rashi identifies the commander as Michael, citing Daniel 10:21 [R5, 5:15].
Saints: The Church’s Synaxis of the Bodiless Powers reads 5:13–15 [L3]. The verse does not itself name the commander; its identity is left open in the translated wording.
Context and interpretation: The omission concerns the report of compliance, not the command about holy ground. Jewish and Christian identifications of the commander remain interpretations of the scene.
Textual sources: BHS (1997), Joshua 5:15 · Rahlfs–Hanhart (2006), Joshua 5:15
2. Rabbinic teaching · Rashi on 5:15
The officer of Adonoy’s host. This refers to Bnei Yisroel, who are Adonoy’s host. The officer mentioned here is the Angel, Michoeil, as it is said, ‘Michoeil, your officer.’
Rashi on Joshua 5:15:1. English: The Book of Joshua, Metsudah Publications, 1997, via Sefaria; license recorded by Sefaria: CC-BY. Selected comment; translator footnotes omitted. Read all comments on the verse.
3. Saints’ teaching. Read St Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 113 with the scope explained in the chapter study. Direct reception already cited in this note retains its stated passage scope.
4. Combined classification · Text: Divergent. Reception at chapter scope: Different. That assessment concerns the named sources and question; it does not assign their position to every word of this verse.
5. How and why. The local note identifies the addition, absence, or rearrangement and its alignment. This establishes the displayed relationship, not the direction of development. Distinguishing expansion, abbreviation, and differing source forms requires witness evidence beyond an English gap.