
2 Maccabees 4 — Latin–Greek comparison
Every source verse remains separate. Open the highlighted English comparison within each card; the five numbered layers distinguish text, Catholic teaching, named non-Catholic readings, combined classification, and origins.
Corrupt office and civic imitation
Jason’s and Menelaus’s rival ambitions link religious office with money and political favor. Onias’s murder and the acquittal of Menelaus intensify the chapter’s criticism of corruption.
Editorial chapter exposition based on the displayed readings. Church sources below supply their stated doctrinal or interpretive scope. Classification method · Tradition and source guide · Disparate studies. Ratings are working English-comparison judgments.
Compare the actual Latin and Greek witnesses through their separate English renderings. Differences of verse division are cross-referenced; they do not establish missing content. All five classifications concern the stated comparison, not the worth of a Christian tradition.
Chapter 4
Jason, Menelaus and the murder of Onias
Latin 4:1 · Greek 4:1Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:1] But the aforesaid Simon, who had informed against the treasury and his homeland, spoke maliciously about Onias, as though he himself had incited Heliodorus to these deeds and had stirred up the troubles.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:1] The aforesaid Simon, who had informed against the funds and his homeland, spoke evil of Onias, alleging that he himself had instigated the attack on Heliodorus and had become the author of the troubles.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “stirred up”; Greek–English has “become the author of”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:1
But the aforesaid Simon, who had informed against the treasury and his homeland, spoke maliciously about Onias, as though he himself had incited Heliodorus to these deeds and had stirred up the troubles.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:1
The aforesaid Simon, who had informed against the funds and his homeland, spoke evil of Onias, alleging that he himself had instigated the attack on Heliodorus and had become the author of the troubles.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:1] Simon autem prædictus, pecuniarum et patriæ delator, male loquebatur de Onia, tamquam ipse Heliodorum instigasset ad hæc, et ipse fuisset incentor malorum :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:2 · Greek 4:2Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:2] He dared to call the city’s guardian, the defender of his nation, and the zealous champion of God’s law a plotter against the kingdom.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:2] He dared to call the city’s benefactor, the guardian of his fellow countrymen and the zealous defender of the laws a conspirator against the government.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “champion”; Greek–English has “defender”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:2
He dared to call the city’s guardian, the defender of his nation, and the zealous champion of God’s law a plotter against the kingdom.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:2
He dared to call the city’s benefactor, the guardian of his fellow countrymen and the zealous defender of the laws a conspirator against the government.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:2] provisoremque civitatis, ac defensorem gentis suæ, et æmulatorem legis Dei, audebat insidiatorem regni dicere.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:3 · Greek 4:3Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:3] When their hostilities advanced so far that even murders were committed through certain associates of Simon,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:3] The hostility advanced so far that murders were committed through one of Simon’s approved supporters.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “When their hostilities”; Greek–English has “The hostility”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:3
When their hostilities advanced so far that even murders were committed through certain associates of Simon,
Septuagint Greek · English 4:3
The hostility advanced so far that murders were committed through one of Simon’s approved supporters.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:3] Sed cum inimicitiæ in tantum procederent ut etiam per quosdam Simonis necessarios homicidia fierent,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:4 · Greek 4:4Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:4] Onias considered the danger of the conflict and the frenzied efforts of Apollonius, as governor of Coelesyria and Phoenicia, to increase Simon’s malice, and went to the king.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:4] Onias saw the danger of the rivalry and that Apollonius son of Menestheus, governor of Coele-Syria and Phoenicia, was increasing Simon’s wickedness.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:4
Onias considered the danger of the conflict and the frenzied efforts of Apollonius, as governor of Coelesyria and Phoenicia, to increase Simon’s malice, and went to the king.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:4
Onias saw the danger of the rivalry and that Apollonius son of Menestheus, governor of Coele-Syria and Phoenicia, was increasing Simon’s wickedness.
Related separate cards: Greek 4:5.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 4:4, 4:5 · Greek 4:4, 4:5. Each verse is displayed separately.
Passage alignment. Onias going to the king opens Greek 4:5 but concludes Latin 4:4.
Latin source and translation notes
[4:4] considerans Onias periculum contentionis, et Apollonium insanire, utpote ducem Cœlesyriæ et Phœnicis, ad augendam malitiam Simonis ad regem se contulit,
Greek 4:4 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
This verse names Apollonius son of Menestheus, whereas 3:5 names Apollonius son of Thraseas. The different patronymics remain visible.
Latin 4:5 · Greek 4:5Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:5] He did not go as an accuser of his fellow citizens, but with the common good of the whole multitude in mind.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:5] He went to the king, not to accuse his fellow citizens but to seek the common and individual benefit of the entire people.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:5
He did not go as an accuser of his fellow citizens, but with the common good of the whole multitude in mind.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:5
He went to the king, not to accuse his fellow citizens but to seek the common and individual benefit of the entire people.
Related separate cards: Greek 4:4.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 4:4, 4:5 · Greek 4:4, 4:5. Each verse is displayed separately.
Latin source and translation notes
[4:5] non ut civium accusator, sed communem utilitatem apud semetipsum universæ multitudinis considerans.
Greek 4:5 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:6 · Greek 4:6Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:6] For he saw that without royal intervention it was impossible to bring peace to affairs, and that Simon could not cease from his folly.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:6] For he saw that without royal intervention public affairs could no longer find peace and Simon would not cease his folly.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “it was impossible to bring”; Greek–English has “public affairs could no longer find”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:6
For he saw that without royal intervention it was impossible to bring peace to affairs, and that Simon could not cease from his folly.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:6
For he saw that without royal intervention public affairs could no longer find peace and Simon would not cease his folly.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:6] Videbat enim sine regali providentia impossibile esse pacem rebus dari, nec Simonem posse cessare a stultitia sua.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:7 · Greek 4:7Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:7] After Seleucus’s death, when Antiochus, who was called the Illustrious, took the kingdom, Jason, Onias’s brother, sought the high priesthood.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:7] When Seleucus departed this life and Antiochus, called Epiphanes, took over the kingdom, Jason, Onias’s brother, obtained the high priesthood by fraud.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “the Illustrious”; Greek–English has “Epiphanes”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:7
After Seleucus’s death, when Antiochus, who was called the Illustrious, took the kingdom, Jason, Onias’s brother, sought the high priesthood.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:7
When Seleucus departed this life and Antiochus, called Epiphanes, took over the kingdom, Jason, Onias’s brother, obtained the high priesthood by fraud.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:7] Sed post Seleuci vitæ excessum, cum suscepisset regnum Antiochus, qui Nobilis appellabatur, ambiebat Jason frater Oniæ summum sacerdotium :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:8 · Greek 4:8Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:8] He approached the king, promising him three hundred sixty talents of silver and eighty talents from other revenues.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:8] In an audience he promised the king three hundred sixty talents of silver, and eighty talents from another source of revenue.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “other revenues”; Greek–English has “another source of revenue”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:8
He approached the king, promising him three hundred sixty talents of silver and eighty talents from other revenues.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:8
In an audience he promised the king three hundred sixty talents of silver, and eighty talents from another source of revenue.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:8] adito rege, promittens ei argenti talenta trecenta sexaginta, et ex redditibus aliis talenta octoginta,
Textual & Reception Notes
Three hundred sixty talents and eighty talents are distinct promises, followed by a further one hundred fifty in verse 9.
Latin 4:9 · Greek 4:9Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:9] Besides these, he promised another hundred fifty if he were granted authority to establish a gymnasium and a training institution for young men, and to enroll the people of Jerusalem as Antiochenes.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:9] Beyond these he promised to pay a further one hundred fifty if he were permitted by royal authority to establish a gymnasium and a training institution for young men, and to enroll the people in Jerusalem as Antiochenes.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “another”; Greek–English has “to pay a further one”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:9
Besides these, he promised another hundred fifty if he were granted authority to establish a gymnasium and a training institution for young men, and to enroll the people of Jerusalem as Antiochenes.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:9
Beyond these he promised to pay a further one hundred fifty if he were permitted by royal authority to establish a gymnasium and a training institution for young men, and to enroll the people in Jerusalem as Antiochenes.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:9] super hæc promittebat et alia centum quinquaginta, si potestati ejus concederetur, gymnasium et ephebiam sibi constituere, et eos qui in Jerosolymis erant, Antiochenos scribere.
4:9 · Translation note. Ephebia denotes an institution for young men; the translation gives a brief functional English rendering. Gymnasium retains its ancient institutional setting, not the narrower meaning of a modern exercise room.
Textual & Reception Notes
γυμνάσιον and ἐφηβεῖον name Greek educational and civic institutions; the latter is not reduced to an ordinary school.
Latin 4:10 · Greek 4:10Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:10] When the king agreed and Jason obtained the office, he immediately began to turn his fellow tribesmen toward Gentile customs.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:10] When the king consented and Jason gained office, he immediately turned his fellow countrymen toward the Greek manner of life.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “Gentile customs”; Greek–English has “the Greek manner of life”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:10
When the king agreed and Jason obtained the office, he immediately began to turn his fellow tribesmen toward Gentile customs.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:10
When the king consented and Jason gained office, he immediately turned his fellow countrymen toward the Greek manner of life.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:10] Quod cum rex annuisset, et obtinuisset principatum, statim ad gentilem ritum contribules suos transferre cœpit,
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:11 · Greek 4:11Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:11] He removed the concessions that the kings had established out of kindness to the Jews through John, the father of Eupolemus, who had undertaken a lawful embassy to the Romans concerning friendship and alliance. Abolishing the rights of the citizens, he sanctioned corrupt institutions.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:11] He set aside the benevolent royal concessions established for the Jews through John, the father of Eupolemus, who had undertaken the embassy to the Romans for friendship and alliance. Abolishing the lawful forms of civic life, he introduced unlawful customs.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “sanctioned corrupt institutions”; Greek–English has “introduced unlawful customs”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:11
He removed the concessions that the kings had established out of kindness to the Jews through John, the father of Eupolemus, who had undertaken a lawful embassy to the Romans concerning friendship and alliance. Abolishing the rights of the citizens, he sanctioned corrupt institutions.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:11
He set aside the benevolent royal concessions established for the Jews through John, the father of Eupolemus, who had undertaken the embassy to the Romans for friendship and alliance. Abolishing the lawful forms of civic life, he introduced unlawful customs.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:11] et amotis his quæ humanitatis causa Judæis a regibus fuerant constituta per Joannem patrem Eupolemi, qui apud Romanos de amicitia et societate functus est legatione legitima, civium jura destituens, prava instituta sanciebat.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:12 · Greek 4:12Disparate
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:12] For he dared to establish a gymnasium directly below the citadel and to place the finest of the young men in brothels.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:12] For he eagerly established a gymnasium immediately beneath the citadel and brought the most distinguished young men under his direction to wear the broad-brimmed hat.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Disparate. The Latin rendering places the young men in brothels; the Greek describes bringing them under the broad-brimmed hat, within Jason’s gymnasium program. This changes a major moral and cultural detail.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:12
For he dared to establish a gymnasium directly below the citadel and to place the finest of the young men in brothels.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:12
For he eagerly established a gymnasium immediately beneath the citadel and brought the most distinguished young men under his direction to wear the broad-brimmed hat.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Disparate. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The Latin source’s lupanaribus supports the published Latin rendering; the Greek-source rendering reflects the hat expression. The English is exposing a source-level problem, not proving that a later church invented it. Its exact transmission history requires a critical apparatus. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:12] Etenim ausus est sub ipsa arce gymnasium constituere, et optimos quosque epheborum in lupanaribus ponere.
4:12 · Translation note. The Latin explicitly reads in lupanaribus, “in brothels.” This conspicuous wording is retained; it has not been harmonized to another textual tradition.
Textual & Reception Notes
πέτασος is the broad-brimmed hat associated here with the young men’s Greek training.
Latin 4:13 · Greek 4:13Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:13] This was not a beginning but a certain increase and advance of the Gentile and foreign way of life, because of the wicked and unheard-of crime of the ungodly Jason, who was no priest.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:13] There was such an upsurge of Hellenism and advance of foreign ways because of the surpassing impurity of the impious Jason, who was no high priest,
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “not a beginning but a certain increase”; Greek–English has “such an upsurge of Hellenism”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:13
This was not a beginning but a certain increase and advance of the Gentile and foreign way of life, because of the wicked and unheard-of crime of the ungodly Jason, who was no priest.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:13
There was such an upsurge of Hellenism and advance of foreign ways because of the surpassing impurity of the impious Jason, who was no high priest,
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:13] Erat autem hoc non initium, sed incrementum quoddam, et profectus gentilis et alienigenæ conversationis, propter impii et non sacerdotis Jasonis nefarium, et inauditum scelus :
Textual & Reception Notes
‘Who was no high priest’ preserves the narrator’s polemical denial despite Jason’s possession of the office.
Latin 4:14 · Greek 4:14Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:14] Thus the priests were no longer devoted to their duties at the altar. Despising the temple and neglecting the sacrifices, they hurried to take part in the wrestling ground, its unlawful provision, and the exercises of the discus.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:14] that the priests were no longer eager for the services of the altar. Despising the temple and neglecting the sacrifices, they hurried to take part in the unlawful provision of exercises in the wrestling ground after the signal for the discus.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “devoted to their duties at”; Greek–English has “eager for the services of”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:14
Thus the priests were no longer devoted to their duties at the altar. Despising the temple and neglecting the sacrifices, they hurried to take part in the wrestling ground, its unlawful provision, and the exercises of the discus.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:14
that the priests were no longer eager for the services of the altar. Despising the temple and neglecting the sacrifices, they hurried to take part in the unlawful provision of exercises in the wrestling ground after the signal for the discus.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:14] ita ut sacerdotes jam non circa altaris officia dediti essent, sed contempto templo et sacrificiis neglectis, festinarent participes fieri palæstræ et præbitionis ejus injustæ, et in exercitiis disci.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:15 · Greek 4:15Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:15] They regarded the honors of their fathers as nothing and considered Greek glories the best.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:15] They regarded their ancestral honors as nothing and considered Greek distinctions the finest.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “glories”; Greek–English has “distinctions”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:15
They regarded the honors of their fathers as nothing and considered Greek glories the best.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:15
They regarded their ancestral honors as nothing and considered Greek distinctions the finest.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:15] Et patrios quidem honores nihil habentes, græcas glorias optimas arbitrabantur :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:16 · Greek 4:16Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:16] For their sake a dangerous rivalry gripped them, and they imitated the institutions of those whom they had as enemies and destroyers, desiring to resemble them in every respect.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:16] For this reason a difficult crisis overtook them: those whose ways they admired and whom they wished to resemble in everything became their enemies and punishers.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “dangerous rivalry gripped”; Greek–English has “difficult crisis overtook”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:16
For their sake a dangerous rivalry gripped them, and they imitated the institutions of those whom they had as enemies and destroyers, desiring to resemble them in every respect.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:16
For this reason a difficult crisis overtook them: those whose ways they admired and whom they wished to resemble in everything became their enemies and punishers.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:16] quarum gratia periculosa eos contentio habebat, et eorum instituta æmulabantur, ac per omnia his consimiles esse cupiebant, quos hostes et peremptores habuerant.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:17 · Greek 4:17Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:17] For acting impiously against the divine laws does not go unpunished; the time that follows will show this.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:17] For acting impiously against the divine laws is no light matter; the ensuing time will show this.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “does not go unpunished”; Greek–English has “is no light matter”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:17
For acting impiously against the divine laws does not go unpunished; the time that follows will show this.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:17
For acting impiously against the divine laws is no light matter; the ensuing time will show this.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:17] In leges enim divinas impie agere impune non cedit : sed hoc tempus sequens declarabit.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:18 · Greek 4:18Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:18] When the games held every fifth year were being celebrated at Tyre, with the king present,
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:18] When the games held every fifth year were being celebrated in Tyre and the king was present,
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “with”; Greek–English has “and”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:18
When the games held every fifth year were being celebrated at Tyre, with the king present,
Septuagint Greek · English 4:18
When the games held every fifth year were being celebrated in Tyre and the king was present,
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:18] Cum autem quinquennalis agon Tyri celebraretur, et rex præsens esset,
Textual & Reception Notes
πενταετηρικός uses the ancient fifth-year designation; the translation retains that expression rather than converting the cycle.
Latin 4:19 · Greek 4:19Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:19] the criminal Jason sent sinful men from Jerusalem carrying three hundred silver didrachms for a sacrifice to Hercules. Those who carried them requested that they not be spent on sacrifices, since that was not proper, but assigned to other expenses.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:19] the defiled Jason sent spectators from Jerusalem, as Antiochenes, carrying three hundred silver drachmas for the sacrifice to Heracles. The bearers themselves asked that these not be used for sacrifice, because it was unfitting, but assigned to another expense.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “Hercules Those who carried them requested”; Greek–English has “Heracles The bearers themselves asked”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:19
the criminal Jason sent sinful men from Jerusalem carrying three hundred silver didrachms for a sacrifice to Hercules. Those who carried them requested that they not be spent on sacrifices, since that was not proper, but assigned to other expenses.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:19
the defiled Jason sent spectators from Jerusalem, as Antiochenes, carrying three hundred silver drachmas for the sacrifice to Heracles. The bearers themselves asked that these not be used for sacrifice, because it was unfitting, but assigned to another expense.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:19] misit Jason facinorosus ab Jerosolymis viros peccatores, portantes argenti didrachmas trecentas in sacrificum Herculis : quas postulaverunt hi qui asportaverant ne in sacrificiis erogarentur, quia non oporteret, sed in alios sumptus eas deputari.
4:19 · Translation note. Didrachms are retained as the named denomination; no modern currency or fixed wage equivalent is substituted.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:20 · Greek 4:20Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:20] Though the money had been offered for a sacrifice to Hercules by the man who sent it, because of those present it was given for the construction of triremes.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:20] Thus, although intended by the sender for the sacrifice to Heracles, the money was applied, through the bearers, to the construction of triremes.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “had been offered for a sacrifice”; Greek–English has “was applied through the bearers”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:20
Though the money had been offered for a sacrifice to Hercules by the man who sent it, because of those present it was given for the construction of triremes.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:20
Thus, although intended by the sender for the sacrifice to Heracles, the money was applied, through the bearers, to the construction of triremes.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:20] Sed hæ oblatæ sunt quidem ab eo qui miserat in sacrificium Herculis : propter præsentes autem datæ sunt in fabricam navium triremium.
4:20 · Translation note. Propter præsentes is literally “because of those present.” Its compressed expression is retained without identifying a motive absent from the Latin.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:21 · Greek 4:21Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:21] When Apollonius son of Menestheus was sent to Egypt on account of the leading men of King Ptolemy Philometor, Antiochus learned that he had been excluded from the affairs of the kingdom. Looking after his own interests, he departed from there, came to Joppa, and then to Jerusalem.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:21] When Apollonius son of Menestheus was sent to Egypt for King Philometor’s accession celebration, Antiochus learned that Philometor had become hostile to his affairs and took thought for his own security. Therefore he came to Joppa and proceeded to Jerusalem.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “been excluded from the”; Greek–English has “become hostile to his”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:21
When Apollonius son of Menestheus was sent to Egypt on account of the leading men of King Ptolemy Philometor, Antiochus learned that he had been excluded from the affairs of the kingdom. Looking after his own interests, he departed from there, came to Joppa, and then to Jerusalem.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:21
When Apollonius son of Menestheus was sent to Egypt for King Philometor’s accession celebration, Antiochus learned that Philometor had become hostile to his affairs and took thought for his own security. Therefore he came to Joppa and proceeded to Jerusalem.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:21] Misso autem in Ægyptum Apollonio Mnesthei filio propter primates Ptolemæi Philometoris regis, cum cognovisset Antiochus alienum se a negotiis regni effectum, propriis utilitatibus consulens, profectus inde venit Joppen, et inde Jerosolymam.
4:21 · Translation note. Propter primates is rendered “on account of the leading men,” preserving the accessed wording rather than silently supplying a coronation or other event.
Textual & Reception Notes
πρωτοκλίσια is rendered provisionally as ‘accession celebration’; the precise court occasion needs specialist review.
Latin 4:22 · Greek 4:22Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:22] Magnificently received by Jason and the city, he entered amid the light of torches and acclamations. From there he turned his army toward Phoenicia.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:22] Received magnificently by Jason and the city, he was welcomed with torches and shouts. Afterward he departed with his army into Phoenicia.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “entered amid the light of”; Greek–English has “was welcomed with”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:22
Magnificently received by Jason and the city, he entered amid the light of torches and acclamations. From there he turned his army toward Phoenicia.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:22
Received magnificently by Jason and the city, he was welcomed with torches and shouts. Afterward he departed with his army into Phoenicia.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:22] Et magnifice ab Jasone et civitate susceptus, cum facularum luminibus et laudibus ingressus est : et inde in Phœnicen exercitum convertit.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:23 · Greek 4:23Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:23] After three years, Jason sent Menelaus, the brother of the aforementioned Simon, to carry money to the king and bring back responses concerning necessary affairs.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:23] After a period of three years, Jason sent Menelaus, brother of the previously mentioned Simon, to convey the money to the king and present memoranda on necessary matters.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “bring back responses concerning”; Greek–English has “present memoranda on”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:23
After three years, Jason sent Menelaus, the brother of the aforementioned Simon, to carry money to the king and bring back responses concerning necessary affairs.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:23
After a period of three years, Jason sent Menelaus, brother of the previously mentioned Simon, to convey the money to the king and present memoranda on necessary matters.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:23] Et post triennii tempus, misit Jason Menelaum supradicti Simonis fratrem portantem pecunias regi, et de negotiis necessariis responsa perlaturum.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:24 · Greek 4:24Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:24] But Menelaus, after being presented to the king and magnifying the display of his power, diverted the high priesthood to himself, offering three hundred silver talents more than Jason.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:24] When introduced to the king, Menelaus impressed him by the appearance of authority and secured the high priesthood for himself by outbidding Jason by three hundred talents of silver.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “But Menelaus after being presented”; Greek–English has “When introduced”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:24
But Menelaus, after being presented to the king and magnifying the display of his power, diverted the high priesthood to himself, offering three hundred silver talents more than Jason.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:24
When introduced to the king, Menelaus impressed him by the appearance of authority and secured the high priesthood for himself by outbidding Jason by three hundred talents of silver.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:24] At ille commendatus regi, cum magnificasset faciem potestatis ejus, in semetipsum retorsit summum sacerdotium, superponens Jasoni talenta argenti trecenta.
Textual & Reception Notes
The phrase ‘appearance of authority’ is compressed; it describes the impression Menelaus made before the king.
Latin 4:25 · Greek 4:25Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:25] Having received the king’s orders, he returned with nothing worthy of the priesthood, but bearing the disposition of a cruel tyrant and the rage of a wild beast.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:25] Having received the royal orders, he returned, bringing nothing worthy of the high priesthood, but possessing the temper of a cruel tyrant and the rage of a savage beast.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “bearing”; Greek–English has “possessing”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:25
Having received the king’s orders, he returned with nothing worthy of the priesthood, but bearing the disposition of a cruel tyrant and the rage of a wild beast.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:25
Having received the royal orders, he returned, bringing nothing worthy of the high priesthood, but possessing the temper of a cruel tyrant and the rage of a savage beast.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:25] Acceptisque a rege mandatis, venit, nihil quidem habens dignum sacerdotio : animos vero crudelis tyranni, et feræ beluæ iram gerens.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:26 · Greek 4:26Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:26] Jason, who had taken his own brother captive, was himself deceived and driven out as a fugitive into the country of the Ammonites.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:26] Jason, who had fraudulently displaced his own brother, was himself displaced by another and driven as a fugitive into the land of the Ammonites.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “deceived”; Greek–English has “displaced by another”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:26
Jason, who had taken his own brother captive, was himself deceived and driven out as a fugitive into the country of the Ammonites.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:26
Jason, who had fraudulently displaced his own brother, was himself displaced by another and driven as a fugitive into the land of the Ammonites.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:26] Et Jason quidem, qui proprium fratrem captivaverat, ipse deceptus profugus in Ammanitem expulsus est regionem.
4:26 · Translation note. Captivaverat is rendered “had taken captive.” Its stronger wording is preserved rather than reduced to a neutral change of office.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:27 · Greek 4:27Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:27] Menelaus obtained the office but did nothing about the money promised to the king, although Sostratus, the commander of the citadel, demanded payment.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:27] Menelaus held the office, but made no regular payment of the funds promised to the king,
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:27
Menelaus obtained the office but did nothing about the money promised to the king, although Sostratus, the commander of the citadel, demanded payment.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:27
Menelaus held the office, but made no regular payment of the funds promised to the king,
Related separate cards: Greek 4:28.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 4:27, 4:28 · Greek 4:27, 4:28. Each verse is displayed separately.
Passage alignment. Sostratus demanding payment is in Greek 4:28 and Latin 4:27; both verses form one aligned unit.
Latin source and translation notes
[4:27] Menelaus autem principatum quidem obtinuit : de pecuniis vero regi promissis, nihil agebat, cum exactionem faceret Sostratus, qui arci erat præpositus,
Greek 4:27 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:28 · Greek 4:28Divergent
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:28] For the collection of revenues belonged to him; for this reason both men were summoned to the king.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:28] although Sostratus, commander of the citadel, demanded them, since collection of the funds belonged to him. For this reason the two men were summoned by the king.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Divergent. The selected verse boundaries redistribute part of this passage. Read the related source verses and the alignment note below together. A clause absent from this individual card is not automatically absent from the other textual tradition.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:28
For the collection of revenues belonged to him; for this reason both men were summoned to the king.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:28
although Sostratus, commander of the citadel, demanded them, since collection of the funds belonged to him. For this reason the two men were summoned by the king.
Related separate cards: Greek 4:27.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Divergent. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The local distribution of clauses and source verse divisions explains at least part of this contrast. Compare the complete neighboring verses before treating any highlighted span as added or omitted material. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Verse alignment. The source editions divide this passage differently. Related verses: Latin 4:27, 4:28 · Greek 4:27, 4:28. Each verse is displayed separately.
Latin source and translation notes
[4:28] nam ad hunc exactio vectigalium pertinebant : quam ob causam utrique ad regem sunt evocati.
Greek 4:28 · Notes
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:29 · Greek 4:29Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:29] Menelaus was removed from the priesthood, his brother Lysimachus succeeding him, while Sostratus was placed over the Cypriots.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:29] Menelaus left his own brother Lysimachus as his deputy in the high priesthood, while Sostratus left Crates, the commander of the Cypriots.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “was placed over”; Greek–English has “left Crates the commander of”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:29
Menelaus was removed from the priesthood, his brother Lysimachus succeeding him, while Sostratus was placed over the Cypriots.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:29
Menelaus left his own brother Lysimachus as his deputy in the high priesthood, while Sostratus left Crates, the commander of the Cypriots.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:29] Et Menelaus amotus est a sacerdotio, succedente Lysimacho fratre suo : Sostratus autem prælatus est Cypriis.
4:29 · Translation note. The Latin states that Menelaus “was removed” and that Lysimachus succeeded him; the translation does not silently replace this with temporary deputizing.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:30 · Greek 4:30Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:30] While these things were taking place, the people of Tarsus and Mallus happened to rise in revolt, because they had been given as a gift to Antiochis, the king’s concubine.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:30] While these things were taking place, the people of Tarsus and Mallus happened to revolt because they had been given as a gift to Antiochis, the king’s concubine.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. The highlighted comparison shows small changes in connective wording, order, or explicit expression. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:30
While these things were taking place, the people of Tarsus and Mallus happened to rise in revolt, because they had been given as a gift to Antiochis, the king’s concubine.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:30
While these things were taking place, the people of Tarsus and Mallus happened to revolt because they had been given as a gift to Antiochis, the king’s concubine.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:30] Et cum hæc agerentur, contigit Tharsenses et Mallotas seditionem movere, eo quod Antiochidi regis concubinæ dono essent dati.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:31 · Greek 4:31Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:31] The king therefore came in haste to pacify them, leaving Andronicus, one of his companions, as his deputy.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:31] The king therefore went quickly to settle the matter, leaving Andronicus, one of the men of high rank, as his deputy.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “his companions”; Greek–English has “the men of high rank”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:31
The king therefore came in haste to pacify them, leaving Andronicus, one of his companions, as his deputy.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:31
The king therefore went quickly to settle the matter, leaving Andronicus, one of the men of high rank, as his deputy.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:31] Festinanter itaque rex venit sedare illos, relicto suffecto uno ex comitibus suis Andronico.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:32 · Greek 4:32Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:32] Menelaus, thinking that he had obtained a favorable opportunity, stole certain gold vessels from the temple and gave them to Andronicus. Other vessels he had sold at Tyre and throughout the neighboring cities.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:32] Menelaus, thinking he had found a favorable opportunity, stole some of the temple’s gold objects and gave them to Andronicus. He had also sold others in Tyre and the surrounding cities.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “neighboring”; Greek–English has “surrounding”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:32
Menelaus, thinking that he had obtained a favorable opportunity, stole certain gold vessels from the temple and gave them to Andronicus. Other vessels he had sold at Tyre and throughout the neighboring cities.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:32
Menelaus, thinking he had found a favorable opportunity, stole some of the temple’s gold objects and gave them to Andronicus. He had also sold others in Tyre and the surrounding cities.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:32] Ratus autem Menelaus accepisse se tempus opportunum, aurea quædam vasa e templo furatus donavit Andronico, et alia vendiderat Tyri, et per vicinas civitates.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:33 · Greek 4:33Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:33] When Onias learned this with certainty, he denounced him, while remaining in a safe place at Antioch near Daphne.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:33] Onias, who had learned these things clearly, denounced them, having withdrawn to a place of asylum at Daphne near Antioch.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “him while remaining in”; Greek–English has “them having withdrawn to”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:33
When Onias learned this with certainty, he denounced him, while remaining in a safe place at Antioch near Daphne.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:33
Onias, who had learned these things clearly, denounced them, having withdrawn to a place of asylum at Daphne near Antioch.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:33] Quod cum certissime cognovisset Onias, arguebat eum, ipse in loco tuto se continens Antiochiæ secus Daphnem.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:34 · Greek 4:34Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:34] Therefore Menelaus approached Andronicus and asked him to kill Onias. Andronicus came to Onias and, giving his right hand with an oath, persuaded him to leave the place of asylum, although Onias suspected him. He immediately killed him, without regard for justice.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:34] Therefore Menelaus took Andronicus aside and urged him to do away with Onias. Andronicus came to Onias, having been persuaded to act deceitfully, greeted him and gave his right hand with oaths. Although under suspicion, he persuaded Onias to leave the asylum and immediately killed him, showing no regard for justice.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “an oath”; Greek–English has “oaths Although under suspicion he”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:34
Therefore Menelaus approached Andronicus and asked him to kill Onias. Andronicus came to Onias and, giving his right hand with an oath, persuaded him to leave the place of asylum, although Onias suspected him. He immediately killed him, without regard for justice.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:34
Therefore Menelaus took Andronicus aside and urged him to do away with Onias. Andronicus came to Onias, having been persuaded to act deceitfully, greeted him and gave his right hand with oaths. Although under suspicion, he persuaded Onias to leave the asylum and immediately killed him, showing no regard for justice.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:34] Unde Menelaus accedens ad Andronicum, rogabat ut Oniam interficeret. Qui cum venisset ad Oniam, et datis dextris cum jurejurando (quamvis esset ei suspectus) suasisset de asylo procedere, statim eum peremit, non veritus justitiam.
Textual & Reception Notes
The Greek sequence of persuasion, oaths and the right-hand pledge is preserved. The killing is stated without adding a method absent from the verse.
Latin 4:35 · Greek 4:35Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:35] For this reason not only the Jews but other nations also were indignant and deeply distressed at the unjust killing of so great a man.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:35] For this reason not only Jews but also many of the other nations were indignant and distressed at the man’s unjust murder.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “killing of so great a man”; Greek–English has “murder”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:35
For this reason not only the Jews but other nations also were indignant and deeply distressed at the unjust killing of so great a man.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:35
For this reason not only Jews but also many of the other nations were indignant and distressed at the man’s unjust murder.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:35] Ob quam causam non solum Judæi, sed aliæ quoque nationes indignabantur, et moleste ferebant de nece tanti viri injusta.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:36 · Greek 4:36Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:36] When the king returned from the districts of Cilicia, the Jews at Antioch, together with the Greeks, approached him and complained about the lawless killing of Onias.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:36] When the king returned from the regions of Cilicia, the Jews in the city petitioned him about the senseless killing of Onias; the Greeks shared their hatred of the wickedness.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “Greeks approached”; Greek–English has “city petitioned”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:36
When the king returned from the districts of Cilicia, the Jews at Antioch, together with the Greeks, approached him and complained about the lawless killing of Onias.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:36
When the king returned from the regions of Cilicia, the Jews in the city petitioned him about the senseless killing of Onias; the Greeks shared their hatred of the wickedness.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:36] Sed regressum regem de Ciliciæ locis adierunt Judæi apud Antiochiam, simul et Græci, conquerentes de iniqua nece Oniæ.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:37 · Greek 4:37Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:37] Antiochus was therefore grieved in spirit over Onias and moved to compassion. He shed tears, remembering the dead man’s self-restraint and modesty.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:37] Antiochus was deeply grieved, moved to pity, and wept because of the deceased man’s self-restraint and great good order.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “compassion He shed tears remembering”; Greek–English has “pity and wept because of”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:37
Antiochus was therefore grieved in spirit over Onias and moved to compassion. He shed tears, remembering the dead man’s self-restraint and modesty.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:37
Antiochus was deeply grieved, moved to pity, and wept because of the deceased man’s self-restraint and great good order.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:37] Contristatus itaque animo Antiochus propter Oniam, et flexus ad misericordiam, lacrimas fudit, recordatus defuncti sobrietatem et modestiam :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:38 · Greek 4:38Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:38] Enraged, he ordered Andronicus to be stripped of his purple robe and led around the whole city. He ordered that sacrilegious man to be deprived of life in the very place where he had committed his impiety against Onias, the Lord repaying him with the punishment he deserved.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:38] Burning with anger, he immediately stripped Andronicus of his purple robe, tore off his tunics, and led him around the whole city to the very place where he had committed the impious act against Onias. There he removed the murderer from life, the Lord rendering him his deserved punishment.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “his impiety”; Greek–English has “the impious act”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:38
Enraged, he ordered Andronicus to be stripped of his purple robe and led around the whole city. He ordered that sacrilegious man to be deprived of life in the very place where he had committed his impiety against Onias, the Lord repaying him with the punishment he deserved.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:38
Burning with anger, he immediately stripped Andronicus of his purple robe, tore off his tunics, and led him around the whole city to the very place where he had committed the impious act against Onias. There he removed the murderer from life, the Lord rendering him his deserved punishment.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:38] accensisque animis Andronicum purpura exutum, per totam civitatem jubet circumduci : et in eodem loco in quo in Oniam impietatem commiserat, sacrilegum vita privari, Domino illi condignam retribuente pœnam.
Textual & Reception Notes
The source’s unusual ἀπεκόσμησεν is represented as ‘removed … from life,’ with execution understood from context.
Latin 4:39 · Greek 4:39Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:39] When Lysimachus had committed many acts of sacrilege in the temple at Menelaus’s suggestion, and the report had spread, the multitude assembled against Lysimachus, much gold having already been carried away.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:39] Many sacrilegious thefts were committed in the city by Lysimachus with Menelaus’s consent, and the report spread abroad. The multitude gathered against Lysimachus, many gold objects having already been carried off.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “When Lysimachus had”; Greek–English has “Many sacrilegious thefts were”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:39
When Lysimachus had committed many acts of sacrilege in the temple at Menelaus’s suggestion, and the report had spread, the multitude assembled against Lysimachus, much gold having already been carried away.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:39
Many sacrilegious thefts were committed in the city by Lysimachus with Menelaus’s consent, and the report spread abroad. The multitude gathered against Lysimachus, many gold objects having already been carried off.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:39] Multis autem sacrilegiis in templo a Lysimacho commissis Menelai consilio, et divulgata fama, congregata est multitudo adversum Lysimachum multo jam auro exportato.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:40 · Greek 4:40Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:40] As the crowds rose and their spirits filled with anger, Lysimachus armed nearly three thousand men and began to use violent hands, under a certain tyrant advanced alike in age and madness.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:40] As the crowds rose up and were filled with anger, Lysimachus armed about three thousand men and began unjust acts of violence, led by a certain Auranus, advanced in age and no less advanced in folly.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “to use violent hands under”; Greek–English has “unjust acts of violence led by”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:40
As the crowds rose and their spirits filled with anger, Lysimachus armed nearly three thousand men and began to use violent hands, under a certain tyrant advanced alike in age and madness.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:40
As the crowds rose up and were filled with anger, Lysimachus armed about three thousand men and began unjust acts of violence, led by a certain Auranus, advanced in age and no less advanced in folly.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:40] Turbis autem insurgentibus, et animis ira repletis, Lysimachus armatis fere tribus millibus iniquis manibus uti cœpit, duce quodam tyranno, ætate pariter et dementia provecto.
4:40 · Translation note. The source has a descriptive tyrannus, rendered “tyrant”; no different personal name is imported.
Textual & Reception Notes
The name Auranus follows Αυρανος in the consulted text.
Latin 4:41 · Greek 4:41Different
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:41] When they understood Lysimachus’s attempt, some seized stones and others stout clubs, while some threw ashes at Lysimachus.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:41] Seeing Lysimachus’s attack, some seized stones, others thick pieces of wood, and some handfuls of the ashes lying nearby, and hurled them in confusion at Lysimachus’s men.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Different. Latin–English has “Lysimachus”; Greek–English has “Lysimachus’s men”. This changes a local detail or emphasis in the displayed renderings; the complete wording and retained source notes delimit the judgment.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:41
When they understood Lysimachus’s attempt, some seized stones and others stout clubs, while some threw ashes at Lysimachus.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:41
Seeing Lysimachus’s attack, some seized stones, others thick pieces of wood, and some handfuls of the ashes lying nearby, and hurled them in confusion at Lysimachus’s men.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Different. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: The difference is visible in the selected renderings. It may involve translation, an inherited reading, or revision; this update does not establish a manuscript chain or a particular copying error for this verse. Consult the retained source-language note before assigning a cause. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:41] Sed ut intellexerunt conatum Lysimachi, alii lapides, alii fustes validos arripuere : quidam vero cinerem in Lysimachum jecere.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:42 · Greek 4:42Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:42] Many were wounded, some were struck down, and all were put to flight. They also killed the sacrilegious man himself beside the treasury.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:42] In this way they wounded many of them, struck down some, and drove them all into flight. They killed the temple-robber himself beside the treasury.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “sacrilegious man”; Greek–English has “temple-robber”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:42
Many were wounded, some were struck down, and all were put to flight. They also killed the sacrilegious man himself beside the treasury.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:42
In this way they wounded many of them, struck down some, and drove them all into flight. They killed the temple-robber himself beside the treasury.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:42] Et multi quidem vulnerati, quidam autem et prostrati, omnes vero in fugam conversi sunt : ipsum etiam sacrilegum secus ærarium interfecerunt.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:43 · Greek 4:43Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:43] Proceedings concerning these matters were therefore begun against Menelaus.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:43] A trial concerning these matters was brought against Menelaus.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “were therefore begun”; Greek–English has “was brought”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:43
Proceedings concerning these matters were therefore begun against Menelaus.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:43
A trial concerning these matters was brought against Menelaus.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:43] De his ergo cœpit judicium adversus Menelaum agitari.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:44 · Greek 4:44Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:44] When the king came to Tyre, three men sent by the elders brought the case before him.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:44] When the king arrived in Tyre, three men sent by the council of elders presented their case before him.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “brought the”; Greek–English has “presented their”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:44
When the king came to Tyre, three men sent by the elders brought the case before him.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:44
When the king arrived in Tyre, three men sent by the council of elders presented their case before him.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:44] Et cum venisset rex Tyrum, ad ipsum negotium detulerunt missi tres viri a senioribus.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:45 · Greek 4:45Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:45] When Menelaus was losing the case, he promised to give Ptolemy large sums of money to persuade the king.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:45] Menelaus, already losing, promised a large sum of money to Ptolemy son of Dorymenes to persuade the king.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “was”; Greek–English has “already”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:45
When Menelaus was losing the case, he promised to give Ptolemy large sums of money to persuade the king.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:45
Menelaus, already losing, promised a large sum of money to Ptolemy son of Dorymenes to persuade the king.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:45] Et cum superaretur Menelaus, promisit Ptolemæo multas pecunias dare ad suadendum regi.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:46 · Greek 4:46Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:46] Ptolemy therefore approached the king, who was in a certain courtyard as if to refresh himself, and drew him away from his decision.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:46] Ptolemy therefore took the king aside into a colonnade, as though for refreshment, and changed his mind.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “if to refresh himself”; Greek–English has “though for refreshment”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:46
Ptolemy therefore approached the king, who was in a certain courtyard as if to refresh himself, and drew him away from his decision.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:46
Ptolemy therefore took the king aside into a colonnade, as though for refreshment, and changed his mind.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:46] Itaque Ptolemæus in quodam atrio positum quasi refrigerandi gratia regem adiit, et deduxit a sententia :
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:47 · Greek 4:47Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:47] The king acquitted Menelaus of the charges, though he was guilty of all the wickedness, but condemned to death the unfortunate men who would have been judged innocent even if they had pleaded their case before the Scythians.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:47] The king acquitted Menelaus, the cause of the entire evil, of the charges, but condemned to death the unfortunate men who would have been released uncondemned even if they had pleaded before Scythians.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “judged innocent”; Greek–English has “released uncondemned”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:47
The king acquitted Menelaus of the charges, though he was guilty of all the wickedness, but condemned to death the unfortunate men who would have been judged innocent even if they had pleaded their case before the Scythians.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:47
The king acquitted Menelaus, the cause of the entire evil, of the charges, but condemned to death the unfortunate men who would have been released uncondemned even if they had pleaded before Scythians.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:47] et Menelaum quidem universæ malitiæ reum criminibus absolvit : miseros autem qui, etiamsi apud Scythas causam dixissent, innocentes judicarentur, hos morte damnavit.
Textual & Reception Notes
The reference to Scythians is the narrator’s rhetorical comparison, not an editorial judgment of a people.
Latin 4:48 · Greek 4:48Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:48] Thus those who had pursued the case on behalf of the city, the people, and the sacred vessels quickly suffered an unjust punishment.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:48] Those who had spoken for the city, the communities and the sacred vessels quickly suffered the unjust penalty.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “pursued the case on behalf of”; Greek–English has “spoken for”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:48
Thus those who had pursued the case on behalf of the city, the people, and the sacred vessels quickly suffered an unjust punishment.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:48
Those who had spoken for the city, the communities and the sacred vessels quickly suffered the unjust penalty.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:48] Cito ergo injustam pœnam dederunt, qui pro civitate, et populo, et sacris vasis causam prosecuti sunt.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:49 · Greek 4:49Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:49] For this reason even the Tyrians were indignant and showed the greatest generosity toward their burial.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:49] For this reason even the Tyrians, hating the wickedness, generously provided for their burial.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “greatest generosity toward”; Greek–English has “wickedness generously provided for”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:49
For this reason even the Tyrians were indignant and showed the greatest generosity toward their burial.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:49
For this reason even the Tyrians, hating the wickedness, generously provided for their burial.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:49] Quam ob rem Tyrii quoque indignati, erga sepulturam eorum liberalissimi extiterunt.
Textual & Reception Notes
Latin 4:50 · Greek 4:50Similar
Latin Vulgate · English rendering
[4:50] But Menelaus, because of the greed of those in power, remained in authority, growing in wickedness as he plotted against the citizens.
Septuagint Greek · English rendering
[4:50] But through the greed of those in power, Menelaus remained in office, growing in wickedness and becoming a great conspirator against his fellow citizens.
1. Direct word comparison and meaning · Similar. Latin–English has “as he plotted”; Greek–English has “and becoming a great conspirator”. The main statement remains substantially shared in this working English comparison.
1. Compare the English wording
Highlighted and underlined spans differ in these English renderings. Word alignment is a reading aid, not an original-language interlinear.
Auto stacks on smaller screens. Side by side can be scrolled horizontally.
Latin Vulgate · English 4:50
But Menelaus, because of the greed of those in power, remained in authority, growing in wickedness as he plotted against the citizens.
Septuagint Greek · English 4:50
But through the greed of those in power, Menelaus remained in office, growing in wickedness and becoming a great conspirator against his fellow citizens.
Text basis: Rahlfs–Hanhart Greek, 2 Maccabees 4; Clementine Latin source. Existing English readings are retained.
2. Modern Catholic explanation, teaching, and understanding. Chapter context: corrupt office and civic imitation. Read this verse within the chapter’s argument. The Catholic framework receives this book as Scripture (CCC 120) and attends to its literary setting (Dei Verbum 12); the chapter exposition is editorial, not a verse-specific magisterial quotation.
3. Medieval Saints / Christians: explanation, teaching, and understanding. St Augustine, City of God XVIII.36 receives Maccabees as canonical in the Church and commends the martyrs’ endurance. This is canonical and book-level context, not a direct gloss on this individual verse.
4. Combined classification: Text · Modern Catholic · Medieval Christians. Latin ↔ Greek: Similar. Modern Catholic ↔ Augustine: Same on canonical reception in the named sources; local interpretation open. CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. Text → interpretation: the cited doctrinal, canonical, or moral scope is stated separately from the wording comparison.
5. How and why the differences arose. Textual explanation: Independent English renderings can vary in vocabulary and syntax while conveying the same main assertion. The highlighting alone does not establish a change in the transmitted Latin or Greek. Reception history: CCC 120 and Augustine’s stated position agree in receiving Maccabees as Scripture. A verse-specific agreement or disagreement requires paired local interpretations. Neither source speaks for every Christian of its period. The historical questions are transmission, later verse division, and interpretive use; disagreement is not assumed from the labels Modern and Medieval.
Source wording and earlier translation / reception notes
Latin source and translation notes
[4:50] Menelaus autem, propter eorum qui in potentia erant avaritiam, permanebat in potestate, crescens in malitia ad insidias civium.
Textual & Reception Notes
The chapter’s repeated language of plotting against fellow citizens is preserved.